Ability of Mitscherlich-Spillman Model to Estimate Critical Soil Phosphate Levels
International Journal of Nutrition and Food Sciences
Volume 2, Issue 2, March 2013, Pages: 45-51
Received: Feb. 17, 2013; Published: Mar. 10, 2013
Views 3193      Downloads 211
Anatoliy V. Pukhovskiy, Moscow State University of Environmental Engineering, Moscow, Russian Federation
Article Tools
Follow on us
More than 150 years research groups from different countries have been studying the effect of various factors on the productivity of the plants described by so-called productivity functions (PF). Interest to PF stems from the needs of economists, agronomists, agricultural chemists and environmentalists who use the PF modeling as a basis for solving their problems. The article describes development of models of productivity for agricultural chemistry and approaches to its calibration. The phenomenon of quasi-linearity (R2> 0.998) of Mitscherlich-Von Boguslawski functions within the range of 30 to 90% efficiency after logarithmic transformation of the argument and practical applications of the method were considered. The limitations were considered in the use of recommendations in relation to the properties of the scale of the studied factors. The approach proposed is applicable to only the values belonging to an absolute scale (ratio scale). The analysis of the possibility and feasibility to assess the so called critical levels of mobile phosphates was made using modeling with recently published Rothamsted long-term experimental data.
Function Of Productivity, Modeling, Model Selection, Available Phosphate
To cite this article
Anatoliy V. Pukhovskiy, Ability of Mitscherlich-Spillman Model to Estimate Critical Soil Phosphate Levels, International Journal of Nutrition and Food Sciences. Vol. 2, No. 2, 2013, pp. 45-51. doi: 10.11648/j.ijnfs.20130202.14
J. Von Liebig, "Die Grundsätze der Agrikulturchemie, mit Rücksicht auf die in England angestellten Untersuchungen," Vieweg, Braunschweig, 1855, p. 107 cited in Yu. Liebig Chemistry in the application to agriculture and physiology . Moscow; Leningrad, 1936. P. 5-36 (in Russian).
C. Ackello-Ogutu, Q. Paris, and W. A. Williams, "Testing a von Licbig Crop Response Funciion against Polynomial Specifications," Amer. J. Agr. Econ, 1985. Vol. 67, pp. 873-80.
R. L. Anderson, and L. A. Nelson, "A family of models involving intersecting straight lines and concomitant expe-rimental designs useful in evaluating response fertilizer nu-trients," Biometrics, 1975, vol.31, pp. 303-318.
P. Berck, and G. Helfand, "Reconciling the von Liebig and Differentiable Crop Production Functions," American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1990, vol.72, pp. 985–996.
D. J.Greenwood, J. T. Wood, T. J. Cleaver, and J. Hunt, "A theory for fertilizer response," Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge, 1971, vol. 77, pp. 511–523.
T. K. Hartz, and P. R. Johnstone, "Relationship between Soil Phosphorus Availability and Phosphorus Loss Potential in Runoff and Drainage," Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 2006,Vol. 37, Issue 11-12, pp. 1525-1536.
E. A. Mitscherlich, "The law of the minimum and the law of diminishing soil productivity," (In German). Landwirtschaf-liche Jahrbuecher , 1909, 38, pp. 537-552. E. A. Mitscherlich, "Soil science for agriculture and forestry," (In German). 2nd edition, Verlag Paul Parey, Berlin, 1913, pp.317 E. A. Mitscherlich, " Die Bestimmung des Düngerbedürfnisses des Bodens," Paul Parey, Berlin, 1924, pp. 100 citied in E.A. Mitscherlich, Soil Science / translation from German lan-guage E.N. Shkonde / under ed. F.V. Turchin. Moscow, 1957. 417 p. (in Russian).
W. J. Spillman, "Application of the Law of Diminishing Returns to Some Fertilizer and Feed Data," Journal of Farm Economics, 1923, vol.5, pp. 36–52.
B. Baule "Mitscherlich's law of physiological relations," Landwirtschafliche Jahrbuecher, 1917, vol.51, pp. 363-385. (In German).
R. H. Bray, "Soil-plant relations. p. I. The quantitative relation of exchangeable K to crop yields and crop response to potash additions," Soil Sci., 1944, vol. 58, pp. 305-324.
R. H. Bray, "Correlation of soil tests with crop response to added fertilizers and with fertilizer requirement," In Diag-nostic techniques for soil and crops. H. B. Kitchen Ed. American Potash Institute, Washington, D. C. 1948, pp. 53-86.
R. H. Bray, "A nutrient mobility concept of soil-plant rela-tionships," Soil Sci., 1954, vol.78, pp. 9-22.
R. H. Bray, and L. T. Kurtz, "Determination of total organic, and available forms of phosphorus in soils," Soil Sci, vol.59, 1945, pp.39-45.
V. E.Boguslawski and B. Schneider, "Die dritte Annaherung des Ertragsgesetzes. 1. Mitteilung,„ Zeitschriftfuer Acker- und Pflanzenbau 114 (3), 1962, pp. 221–236.
V. E. Boguslawski, and B. Schneider, „Die dritte Annaherung des Ertragsgesetzes. 2. Mitteilung," Zeitschrift fuer Acker- und Pflanzenbau 116 (2) ,1963, pp. 113–128.
V. E. Boguslawski, and B. Schneider ,"Die dritte Annaherung des Ertragsgesetzes. 3. Mitteilung,"Zeitschrift fuer Acker- und Pflanzenbau 119, 1964, pp. 1–28.
B. R. Bock, and F. J. Sikora, "Modified-Quadratic Plateau Model for Describing Plant Response to Fertilizer," Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. J., 1990, vol. 54, pp. 1784-1789.
B. W. Brorsen, and F.G.C. Richter, "Experimental Designs for Estimating Plateau-Type Production Functions and Eco-nomically Optimal Input Levels," Journal of Productivity Analysis, 2011, pp. 35.
R. В. Cate, and L. A. Nelson, "A simple statistical procedure for partitionin soil test correlation data into two classes," Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc., 1971, vol.35, pp.658-659.
F. R. Cox, "Economic Phosphorus Fertilization Using a Linear Response and Plateau Function," Comm. Soil Sci. Plant Anal., 1996, vol.27, pp. 531-43.
F. R. Cox, "Range in Soil Phosphorus Critical Levels with Time", Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. J., 1992, vol.56, pp. 1504-09.
C. T. De Wit, and J. Goudriaan," Simulation of Ecological Processes," (2nd edition). Pudoc, Wageningen, 1978, 175 pp.
C. T. De Wit, "Resource use efficiency in agriculture," Agricultural Systems ., 1992, vol. 40, pp. 125-151.
M. D. Frank, B. R. Beattie, and M. E. Embleton, "A Com-parison of Alternative Crop Response Models," American Journal of Agricultural Economics 1990, vol.72, pp. 597–603.
S. S. Grimm, Q. Paris , and W. A. Williams, "A von Liebig Model for Water and Nitrogen Crop Response," Western Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1987, V. 12, No. 2, pp. 182-192.
D. J.Greenwood, J. T. Wood, T. J. Cleaver, and J. Hunt, "A theory for fertilizer response," Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge, 1971, vol. 77, pp. 511–523.
K. Harmsen, "A modified Mitscherlich equation for rainfed crop production in semi-arid areas. p. 1. Theory," Netherlands Journal of Agricultural Science, 2000, vol.48, pp. 237-250.
R. W. Hexem, V. A. Sposito, and E. O. "Heady Applications of a Two-Variable Mitschcrlich Function in the Analysis of Yield-Water-Fertilizer Relationships for Corn," Water Resour. Res., 1976, vol. 12 pp.6-I0.
G. V. Johnson, "General-Model for Predicting Crop Re-sponse to Fertilizer,"Agron. J., 1991, Vol. 83. N. 2, pp 367-373.
G. Liebscher, "Untersuchungen über die Bestimmung des Düngerbedürfnisses der Ackerboeden und Kulturpflanzen," Journal für Landwirtschaft, 1895, 43, pp. 49–216.
L. Michaelis, and M. L. Menten, "Die Kinetik der Invert-wirkung. Biochemische Zeitschrift," 1913, 49, pp. 337–369.
G. O., Nijland, J.Schouls and J.Goudriaan "Integrating the production functions of Liebig, Michaelis–Menten, Mit-scherlich and Liebscher into one system dynamics model," NJAS - Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences 2008. vol.55, No 2, pp. 199-224.
Ivanova T.I. Results of use of increasing doses of mineral fertilizers in crop // Application of mathematical methods in agrochemistry research : Writings of All-Russian Institute of Fertilizers and Agropedology. Moscow, 1977. Iss. 56. pp. 15-51(in Russian).
A.V. Pukhovskiy "Efficiency of phosphorus fertilizers taking into consideration their aftereffect" Melioration and water management (Melioraciya I vodnoe khoziaistvo)/ Moscow. 2011. No. 3. P. 12–14 (in Russian).
Pukhovskiy A.V. "Methodic of evaluation of fertilizers and chemical meliorants payback" Agrochemical bulletin (Agrokhimicheskiy Vestnik). Moscow. 2010. No. 1. P. 35-40(in Russian).
A. E. Johnston "Efficient Use of Nutrients in Agricultural Production Systems," Commun. Soil sci. Plant anal., 2000; vol.31, No11-14, pp. 1599-1620.
L. Jordan-Meille, G. H. Rubæk, P. A. I. Ehlert, V. Genot, G. Hofman, K. Goulding, J. Recknagel Provolo G., and P. Bar-raclough "An overview of fertilizer P recommendations in Europe. p. soil testing, calibration and fertilizer recommen-dations," Soil Use and Management, 2012.Vol. 28, Issue 4, pp. 419–435.
P. J. A. Kleinman, R. B. Bryant, W. S. Reid, A. N. Sharpley, and D. Pimentel, " Using soil phosphorus behavior to iden-tify environmental thresholds," Soil Science, 2000, vol.165, pp.943-950.
P. A. Matson, R. Naylor, I. Ortiz-Monasterio, "Integration of Environmental, Agronomic, and Economic Aspects of Ferti-lizer Management," Science, 1998.vol. 280, pp.112-115.
R. W. McDowell, and A. N. Sharpley "Approximating phosphorus release from soils to surface runoff and subsur-face drainage," J. Environ. Qual. 2001,vol. 30, pp.508–520. http./www.ars.usda.gov/SP2UserFiles/Place/19020000/PhosphorousPubs/JEQ30p508.pdf.
R. Mcdowell, A. Sharpley, P. Brookes, and P. Poulton "Re-lationship Between Soil Test Phosphorus and Phosphorus Release to Solution," Soil sci. 2001; vol. 166, No 2, pp. 137-149.
A. E. Johnston, and P. R.Poulton "Response of cereals to soil and fertilizer phosphorus," HGCA Research Review, No. 74, Rothamsted Research, Harpenden, 2011, 54 pp.
A. E. Johnston, and P. R. Poulton, "Plant available soil phosphorus. Part I. p. the response of winter wheat and spring barley to Olsen P on a silty clay loam," Soil Use and Management, 2012, Wiley Online Library.
A. E. Johnston, and P. R. Poulton, "Plant available soil phosphorus. Part II. p. the response of arable crops to Olsen P on a sandy clay loam and a silty clay loam ," Soil Use and Management, 2012, Wiley Online Library.
A.V. Pukhovskiy, N.F. Khokhlov, "Method of approxima-tion and calibrating of the model of Mitscherlich - Spillman – Baule – Boguslawski Russian Agricultural Sciences. February 2011, Vol. 37, Is. 1, pp 46-50 Original Russian Text © A.V. Pukhovskii, N.F. Khokhlov, 2011, published in Doklady Rossiiskoi Akademii Sel’skokhozyaistvennykh Nauk, 2011, No. 1, pp. 31–34. (in Russian).
A.V. Pukhovskiy, A.V. Efremov, T.Yu. Pukhovskaya "About the method of boundary curve in "coordinate" agri-culture," Fertility (Plodorodie). 2004. No. 3. P. 25(in Rus-sian).
A.V.Pukhovskiy, "Peculiarities of statistical manipulations of results of agrochemical research," Agrochemistry (Agrokhimia). 2001. No. 9. P. 66–74 (in Russian).
A.V. Pukhovskiy, Multielements extragent and metods of agrochemical survey: conceptions, principles and prospects. – Moscow, 2003. – 102 p (in Russian).
"Status and Methods of Research in Economic and Agro-nomic Aspects of Fertilizer Response and Use," Publication 918, National Academy of Sciences—National Research Council, 1961, 89 p.
M. E. Sumner, "Field Experimentation: Changing to Meet Current and Future Needs," Soil Testing: Sampling, Corre-lation, Calibration, and Interpretation. /Ed. Brown J. R SSSA Special Publication Number 21 Soil Science Society of America, Inc. Madison, Wisconsin, USA, 1987, pp.119-132.
Science Publishing Group
1 Rockefeller Plaza,
10th and 11th Floors,
New York, NY 10020
Tel: (001)347-983-5186