1. Introduction
Financial statement analysis is the practice of examining reported financial data, particularly yearly and quarterly reports, in order to determine a company's risk and profitability. Additionally, Bruce Mackenzie (2012) asserts that it is a crucial instrument for comprehending the financial performance of any business. This enables the assessment of a company's present standing about its commercial advantages (such as its clientele) and disadvantages (such as fluctuating expenses). Brigham and Huston (2013) suggest that analyzing financial statements has a number of benefits. First-hand significance includes giving investors a sense of which company to invest in, ensuring that regulatory bodies (such as the IASB) are aware that the company is adhering to the necessary accounting standards, assisting government agencies in assessing the taxes due to the company, and, most importantly, enabling the company to assess its own performance over a given time period. However, financial statement analysis is a very effective tool for a range of financial statement readers, each with a distinct goal in mind: to understand the entity's financial situation
[7] | Brigham, E. F. and Houston, J. F., (2013), Fundamentals of financial management 13th edition, South-Western Cengage Learning. |
[7]
.
Various financial statements highlight distinct aspects of financial performance. A financial analysis, also known as accounting analysis or financial statement analysis, is an evaluation of the feasibility, stability, and profitability of a project, business, or sub-enterprise
[20] | Ravichandran and M. Venkata Subramanian, (2016): “A Study on Financial Performance Analysis of Force Motors Limited,” IJIRST-International Journal for Innovative Research in Science & Technology 2, no. 11. |
[20]
. The first is the financial situation, which is the main issue for its creditors and investors. Investors and creditors, who supply cash, depend on a company's financial health to ensure the security and profitability of their investments. In particular, creditors and investors must be aware of the whereabouts of their funds
[6] | Bragg, S. M., (2012): Financial analysis: a controller's guide, John Wiley and Sons. |
[11] | Elliot, B. and Elliot, J., (2008). Financial Accounting and Report. |
[6, 11]
. By offering comprehensive details about the business's investment assets, the balance sheet's financial statement resolves these problems
[11] | Elliot, B. and Elliot, J., (2008). Financial Accounting and Report. |
[11]
. In order to help debt and equity investors better understand their respective roles in a company's capital mix, it also provides the outstanding debt and equity components of the business. A company’s financial statements provide various important information that investors and creditors use to evaluate a company’s financial performance. Similarly, financial statements are also believed to be important to a company’s managers, as they are producing financial statements in order to communicate with interested inside and outside parties of the company. With insiders, they share financial performance information about its accomplishment towards running the company, while with outsiders, they give a clear picture of where the company is going
[6] | Bragg, S. M., (2012): Financial analysis: a controller's guide, John Wiley and Sons. |
[6]
.
Users of financial statement analysis include government agencies, regulatory bodies, creditors, investors, and/or shareholders, among others. For example, creditors anyone who has given money to a business and is concerned about its capacity to repay the amount they oweare closely monitoring the cash flow metrics of that business. On the other hand, depending on their investment philosophies and strategies, internal and external investors critically review the financial statements to gain insight into a company's capacity to continue paying dividends, generate additional cash flow, or grow the business at its historical rate
[17] | Majid, U., (2018): Research fundamentals: Study design, population, and sample size: Undergraduate research in natural and clinical science and technology journal, 2, pp. 1-7. |
[17]
. The second focus of financial statements is on the performance of operating results, which are shown in the balance sheet of a company’s assets, liabilities, and equity at the end of a financial reporting period, as they don’t reveal what happened during the period from operations that may have caused changes in any of the financial conditions. Therefore, operating results during the period also concern investors in this particular perspective
[6] | Bragg, S. M., (2012): Financial analysis: a controller's guide, John Wiley and Sons. |
[11] | Elliot, B. and Elliot, J., (2008). Financial Accounting and Report. |
[6, 11]
.
There are various broad categories of ratios, each aimed at assessing a distinct aspect of a company's performance. The commonly utilized groups of ratios for analyzing financial performance include liquidity ratios, leverage ratios, profitability ratios, efficiency ratios, and market value ratios. For example, liquidity ratios are regarded as the most crucial and extensively used set of ratios, as they evaluate a company's capacity to manage short-term obligations to continue operating in the business. Conversely, leverage ratios indicate the degree to which a company depends on debt to finance its operations, reflecting its capacity to meet both short-term and long-term obligations. Meanwhile, profitability ratios are key metrics that assess a company's efficiency in generating profit while managing its expenses & the second focus of financial statement is on the performance of operating results which are shown in the balance sheet of a company’s assets, liabilities and equity at the end of a financial reporting period, as they don’t reveal what happened during the period from operation that they may have caused changes in any of financial conditions. Therefore, operating results during the period also concerns investor in this particular perspective
[18] | MUHARAM, H. (2018). Interdependency of Investment and Financing with Financial Constrains. Journal Transylvanian Review, 26(25). |
[18]
.
Moreover, operating outcomes including sales, expenses, and the company's profit or loss are reported in the income statement's financial statement. The use of income statement data is justified by the fact that it allows investors to assess the unpredictability of a company's future cash flows as well as its historical income performance. Thirdly, by calculating accounting income and probably some non-cash components that don't directly reveal a company's cash exchange during the reporting period, financial analysts concentrate on how a company's cash flow performance is presented in both the income statement and the balance sheet over the designated time period
[18] | MUHARAM, H. (2018). Interdependency of Investment and Financing with Financial Constrains. Journal Transylvanian Review, 26(25). |
[18]
.
As a result, it is essential to evaluate the listed lease financing and capital business businesses' financial performance using their financial statements from the beginning. In order to give a clear picture of how the business uses its financial assets, the researcher will do this by using the three main financial statement documents the cash flow, income statement, and balance sheet to compute ratio analysis in the areas of liquidity, leverage, profitability, and efficiency. Leasing firms are crucial to the financing of small and medium-sized enterprises, which require capital to grow but frequently lack the collateral or credit history needed to obtain credit from traditional finance sources.
In the literature, leasing has been defined in a variety of ways. Bruce (1988) defined equipment leasing as a contract in which the lessor, who owns the equipment, agrees to allow the lessee to use the equipment in exchange for regular rental payments. According to IAS 17, a lease is defined as a transaction in which the lessor grants the lessee the right to use an asset for a predetermined amount of time in exchange for a payment or series of payments. According to
[15] | Idhayajothi, R., & Latasri, O. T. V. (2015). A study on performance of SBI mutual funds in Tiruchirapalli district of Tamilnadu. International Journal of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences, 4(6). |
[15]
, a leasing organization must draw in matching funds to fund the leasing program. Leasing companies that offer leases with maturities of two or three years require medium-term financial resources on the liabilities side of their balance sheet. Leasing firms typically rely on capital markets for debt and equity rather than accepting deposits. The medium-term loan required to fund the leasing plan can be hard to find in developing nations. Ethiopia has legislation tailored to the leasing industry. proclamation No. 103/1998, the first leasing proclamation, was published in 1998 and provides a comprehensive legislative framework for the leasing sector. However, it may be argued that, in addition to operating leasing, this remark hasn't really accomplished its goal because financing leasing and hire-purchase haven't actually existed for the last sixteen years or so. Microfinance institutions are allowed to provide financial leasing services under the micro-financing business proclamation No. 626/2009; however, due to a lack of leasing competence, this product has not been offered in a meaningful and professional manner Leasing is a very versatile financing option with a number of benefits. The fact that the leased asset serves as the primary security in a lease agreement is among the most significant benefits of leasing. Leasing is a method used by businesses worldwide to finance automobiles, machinery, and equipment.
Up to one-third of private investment in industrialized (OECD) nations is financed through leasing, according to
[15] | Idhayajothi, R., & Latasri, O. T. V. (2015). A study on performance of SBI mutual funds in Tiruchirapalli district of Tamilnadu. International Journal of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences, 4(6). |
[15]
. Since leasing enables SMEs to develop and modernize their operations, it boosts productivity, reduces transaction costs, creates more job opportunities, increases business profitability, encourages creativity and innovation, and expands product options (World Bank, 2015).
While leasing can be traced back thousands of years, the leasing industry has evolved significantly over the past 50 years
[15] | Idhayajothi, R., & Latasri, O. T. V. (2015). A study on performance of SBI mutual funds in Tiruchirapalli district of Tamilnadu. International Journal of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences, 4(6). |
[15]
. Modern leasing emerged in the 1950s as a specialized financial service industry in the United States and expanded to Europe and Japan in the 1960s and has been spreading through developing countries since the mid-1970s (Todd, Mulder & Nair, 2004). The global leasing performance, as indicated in the World Leasing Yearbook 2014, reported that annual leasing volume in 2013 was USD 868 billion.
The US, China, Germany, and Japan accounted for 60% of global leasing volume, according to this data. With over 30% of the global leasing market, the US is the leading player in the sector, according to the White
[21] | Mackenzie, B., (2012): Interpretation and Application of International Financial Reporting Standards 2012/Bruce Mackenzie, Danie Coetsee, Blaise Colyvas, Tapiwa Njikizana, Raymond Chamboko, Brandon Hanekom. |
[21]
. According to the Equipment Leasing and Finance Association, the entire equipment-leasing market in the US is worth $650 billion, or around 5.9% of the real GDP in 2008
[27] | Schensul, J. J. and LeCompte, M. D., (2012): Essential ethnographic methods: A mixed methods approach (Vol. 3). Rowman Altamira. |
[27]
. However, the African leasing market is still very young, accounting for only 1% of global leasing volume in 2012. In 2013, the Ethiopian government issued the Capital Goods Leasing Business (Amendment) Proclamation No. 807/2013, which clarified the functions of the National Bank of Ethiopia (NBE) and the Ministry of Trade, in response to a number of issues. The Ministry of Trade was entrusted with licensing and overseeing operating lease businesses, while NBE was given the duty of licensing, regulating, and overseeing capital goods finance companies, including finance lease and hire-purchase activities, under Capital Goods Leasing Business Proclamation No. 807/2013. A more favorable legal and regulatory environment for lease firms was established as a result of this distinct separation of powers. Five capital goods finance business companies, mostly owned and backed by regional governments, have been licensed by the NBE since the beginning of 2014. Since then, several businesses have begun providing leasing services in various localities. Ethiopia now has six capital goods finance companies: Addis Capital Share Companies, Waliya, Oromia, Kaza, Debub, and Ethio-Lease Ethiopian Capital Goods Finance Business Share Company. Nevertheless, Ethio-Lease has shut down, leaving five businesses in operation. These companies' financial statements will be examined using secondary data from the NBE for the 2014–2024 timeframe (NBE, 2024; NBE Quarterly Bulletin Vol. 39(4): 2022/23, 4th Quarter).
1.1. Statement of the Problem
In order to conduct its operations and accomplish its goals or objectives, each firm, regardless of size, requires financial performance insights to sustain stability. A company's finances are thought to be its lifeblood. One of the fundamental pillars of all corporate operations in the contemporary economy is finance
[14] | Hailekiros et al, (2020). Lease financing for Competitiveness and Expansion of SMEs in Tigrai: Challenges and Strategic Solutions; Vol. 2, No. 1: May, 2020, pp. 1-20. |
[14]
. The main purpose of financial statements is to aid in decision-making by both inside and outside of a corporation. In order to operate smoothly, raise money from the least expensive and riskiest sources, and/or make the best use of its financial resources, every firm requires finance and its information. The importance of evaluating the financial performance of businesses at any level has been established by many literatures pertaining to the financial performance of various industry sectors. For example, a notable study by
[2] | Amalendu Bhunia, Sri Somnath Mukhuti and Sri Gautam Roy, (2011) “Financial Performance Analysis-A Case Study,” Current Research Journal of Social Sciences 3, no. 3: 269-275. |
[2]
measured the liquidity, profitability, and stability of two public sector drug and pharmaceutical companies listed on the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and found that both companies provide sufficient returns to shareholders to sustain at least their market value.
However, a study on City Union Bank's financial performance by
[9] | Dahmash, F. N. (2015). Size effect on company profitability: Evidence from Jordan. International Journal of Business Management, 10(2), 58-72. |
[9]
revealed that the bank was able to meet all of its capital expenditure and working capital commitment requirements with a higher volume of operations and operating cash flows. In a similar vein,
[15] | Idhayajothi, R., & Latasri, O. T. V. (2015). A study on performance of SBI mutual funds in Tiruchirapalli district of Tamilnadu. International Journal of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences, 4(6). |
[15]
examined Ashok Leyland Company Ltd.'s financial performance and recommended that the company boost sales volume and gross profit.
[23] | Todd, R., Mulder, A. and Nair, A., (2004): Leasing: an underutilized tool in rural finance (No. 31371, pp. 1-0), The World Bank. |
[23]
examined the various ratios influencing profitability and made the strong recommendation that the company focus on its selling, operating, and administrative costs while cutting them. According to this international literature, evaluating the financial performance of businesses in any sector or industry is significant since it provides crucial financial measures that are necessary to understand the company's position. Furthermore, the world leasing industry saw a remarkable 9.3% increase in 2021 as equipment investment recovered and global economies emerged from lockdown
[30] | Solfi, (2023) Global Leasing Report. |
[30]
. In 2021, the top 50 nations reported a new volume of USD 1,463.19 billion, up from USD 1,338.19 billion in 2020. The data also reveals that the worldwide leasing business has increased by 84% over the previous many years.
North America, Europe, and Asia make up 96% of the global leasing volume, whereas South America saw a very amazing 74% increase, Australia and New Zealand saw a 1.1% increase, and, most significantly, Africa saw a 9.3% increase. This demonstrates the fast rise in the volume of leasing activity worldwide, which urgently necessitates in-depth investigation and evaluation of the capital goods finance industry in Sub-Saharan Africa, including Ethiopia. SMEs in Ethiopia have very limited access to bank credit and other financial services, such as capital goods lease financing companies, according to a number of studies
[15] | Idhayajothi, R., & Latasri, O. T. V. (2015). A study on performance of SBI mutual funds in Tiruchirapalli district of Tamilnadu. International Journal of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences, 4(6). |
[15]
. This is because SMEs lack the collateral and credit history necessary to obtain the majority of traditional bank financing. According to World Bank research on SMEs financing in Ethiopia in 2015, only 3% of small businesses and 23% of medium-sized businesses have a loan facility or line of credit. This is primarily because the collateral required for loans is extremely high, accounting for 249.3% and 253.5% of small and medium-sized business loans, respectively, compared to the average of 160% for Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). However, despite evaluating these organizations' stability in relation to their financial resource allocation, their financial performances have garnered notice.
The expansion of the leasing sector as a financing delivery method broadens the market's selection of financial products and is therefore seen as a means of giving businesses that would not otherwise have access to financing a way to do so, thereby fostering domestic production, economic expansion, and job creation (IFC, 2005). By determining their stability in granting access to financing and, in turn, income-producing assets, leasing finance development also enables smaller-scale enterprises to become more economically active. Additionally, in any economy, SMEs in particular and the economy as a whole benefit from the growth of the leasing sector if their financial performance is carefully examined. Unfortunately, the lack of well-defined and reliable regulatory frameworks governing leasing industry transactions causes structural and leverage issues in many developing nations. According to
[25] | Olana, A. A., (2016). Lease financing in Ethiopia: an assessment of five regulated lease financing companies (Addis Ababa University). |
[25]
, it is also clear that the absence of appropriate legal frameworks led to unclear accounting standards, inadequate tax regimes, limited funding capabilities, and unclear application and interpretation due to a lack of prior experience. According to
[13] | Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia (FDRE) (1998): ‘Capital Goods Leasing Business’ Proclamation No. 103/1998 (Addis Ababa, Federal Negarit gazette 4th year No. 27 March, 1998). |
[13]
, the industry lacks clarity in tax, legal, and accounting elements, particularly in leasing. The underdevelopment of the sector was also attributed to a lack of public awareness, a shortage of qualified professionals in the market, and the burden of high interest rates.
Therefore, the purpose of this study is to analyze financial statement data from the National Bank of Ethiopia and primary data from samples of five lease financing companies in order to investigate the factors that influence the financial performance of the nation's capital goods finance business for the period spanning from 2014 to 2023.
1.2. Research Hypothesis
Ha1: There is positive & significant relationship between regulatory environment & financial performance of lease financing companies.
Ha2: There is a positive and significant association between business size & the financial performance of lease financing companies.
Ha3: There is positive and significant relationship between asset type and lease finance companies' financial performance are related.
Ha4: There is positive and significant relationship between tax breaks &lease financing companies' financial performance.
Ha5: Fund accessibility has positive and significant relation with lease financing company’s financial performance.
1.3. Objective of the Study
This study's main goal is to investigate the variables influencing the financial performance of particular Ethiopian lease financing firms. The specific objectives of the study are to:
1) examine the impact of the regulatory environment on the financial performance of lease financing companies
2) investigate how business size affects the financial performance of lease financing companies
3) investigate how asset type and lease finance companies' financial performance are related
4) find out how tax breaks impact lease financing companies' financial performance
5) ascertain and analyze the impact of fund accessibility on lease financing organizations' financial performance.
2. Review of Related Literature
2.1. Theoretical Literature Review
Financial performance has been a concern for investors and stakeholders, which has led to study attempts to find out what elements influence leasing firms' financial success. For any economy to expand and develop, its financial performance is essential. Strong competitiveness, a high return on investment for shareholders, the creation of jobs, and a rise in an economy's gross domestic product (GDP) are thus the outcomes of a company's financial performance. The industry's competitiveness, economic stability, and the rewards to important stakeholders can all be negatively impacted by a protracted crisis that is brought on by subpar financial performance
[29] | Shall and Haley, (11), Introduction to Financial Management. 6th ed. Singapore: McGraw-Hill, pp. 241. |
[29]
. Therefore, managers must balance the interests of all groups in order to maximize the interest of all agencies. This will reduce the potential negative impacts and the repercussions of divergent reactions on financial performance
[5] | Bloomfield, J. and Fisher, M. J., (2019): Quantitative research design; Journal of the Australasian Rehabilitation Nurses Association, 22(2), pp. 27-30. |
[5]
. Among other things, one of the most basic realities about businesses is that their financial performance determines their financial structure and whether they have the liquidity they need to meet their financial responsibilities. Stated differently, a company's financial performance is the monetary outcome of its activities and policies. The way businesses employ their limited resources to accomplish their stated aims is reflected in their financial performance. It is crucial to remember that there is no one ideal way for a company to gauge performance. It follows that choosing the optimal course of action depends heavily on the organization's goals and nature. Crucially, the investment firm, lessors, lessees, and all investors depend on the firm's performance. For example, because they are interested in the market price of their investments, investors focus on both the present returns and the possibility of future earnings
[24] | Nguyen, T. S., (2019): The effect of logistics service on firm financial performance in textile industry: evidence from Da Nang city, Vietnam; In MATEC Web of Conferences (Vol. 259, p. 04002). |
[24]
. In particular, financial performance is a measure of an industry's revenue or profit that demonstrates how the overall value of the firm has increased as a result of the recognition of a company's merit.
Studies on the financial performance of various industries
[5] | Bloomfield, J. and Fisher, M. J., (2019): Quantitative research design; Journal of the Australasian Rehabilitation Nurses Association, 22(2), pp. 27-30. |
[5]
assessed the liquidity, stability, and profitability of two public drug and pharmaceutical companies listed on the BSE and made sure that both businesses provided sufficient returns to shareholders to preserve at least their market value. With a higher volume of activities and operational cash flows, City Union Bank was able to meet all of its criteria for capital expenditures and a higher level of working capital commitment
[29] | Shall and Haley, (11), Introduction to Financial Management. 6th ed. Singapore: McGraw-Hill, pp. 241. |
[29]
. According to
[34] | World Bank (2015), SME Finance in Ethiopia: Addressing the Missing Middle Challenge. Washington, DC. |
[34]
, leasing is one of the more efficient ways to support the Ethiopian economy by giving SMEs long-term financing. Supporting leasing firms and other financial institutions that cater to SMEs is therefore a successful strategy for funding them (IFC, 2009). Small and medium-sized enterprises, which require capital to grow but frequently lack the credit history or collateral necessary for loans from traditional financing sources, are largely financed by leasing companies.
Leasing is a very versatile financing option with a number of benefits. The fact that the leased asset serves as the primary security in a lease agreement is among the most significant benefits of leasing. Leasing is a method used by businesses worldwide to finance automobiles, machinery, and equipment. Up to one-third of private investment in industrialized (OECD) nations is financed through leasing, according to the ILO (2003). Since leasing enables SMEs to develop and modernize their operations, it boosts productivity, reduces transaction costs, creates more job opportunities, increases business profitability, encourages creativity and innovation, and expands product options (World Bank, 2015).
According to
[33] | Weeks, J. R., (2020): Population: An introduction to concepts and issues. Cengage Learning. |
[33]
, modern leasing began as a specialized financial service industry in the United States in the 1950s and moved to Europe and Japan in the 1960s. Since the mid-1970s, it has also been expanding throughout emerging nations. According to the World Leasing Year Book (2014), the global leasing performance showed that the annual leasing volume in 2013 was USD 868 billion. The United States, China, Germany, and Japan accounted for 60% of global leasing volume, according to this data. According to the White (Clarke Global Leasing Report 2012), the United States holds a prominent position in the leasing business, accounting for over 30% of the global market.
The US equipment leasing business is valued at $650 billion, or around 5.9% of the nation's real GDP in 2008, according to the Equipment Leasing and Finance Association
[27] | Schensul, J. J. and LeCompte, M. D., (2012): Essential ethnographic methods: A mixed methods approach (Vol. 3). Rowman Altamira. |
[27]
. However, given that Africa only made up 1% of the world's leasing volume in 2012, the continent's leasing business is still in its infancy. White Clarke Global Leasing Report (2013). According to
[16] | International Finance Corporation (IFC 2009), Leasing in Development: Guidelines for Emerging Economies, Washington DC. |
[16]
, leasing enterprises depend heavily on capital. In contrast to bank-owned leasing companies that have access to bank finance, stand-alone leasing companies lack a parent from which to obtain guaranteed capital. Therefore, independent leasing businesses without safe financing may find that their funding sources completely vanish, and even if they do, their cost of money will unavoidably increase, which will impact not only their profitability but also their capacity to on-lend at a fair rate.
[16] | International Finance Corporation (IFC 2009), Leasing in Development: Guidelines for Emerging Economies, Washington DC. |
[16]
recommended that leasing businesses be permitted to mobilize term deposits, but not demand deposits, in order to achieve this goal.
2.2. Empirical Literature Review
There are a number of important aspects that influence how well lease companies perform; they include the following:
2.2.1. Regulatory Framework for Leasing
Since lessors are typically not permitted to draw deposits, their prudential rules are typically less stringent than those of banks. Nevertheless, minimal prudential rules are beneficial to both lessees and shareholders. This contributes to the leasing industry's continued stability and vibrancy
[32] | V. P. T. Dhevika, O. T. V. Latasri and H. Gayathiri, (2013): “A Study on Financial Performance Analysis at City Union Bank,” International Journal of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences 2, no. 7: 53-67. |
[32]
. Typically, a nation's Ministry of Finance or Central Bank is in charge of regulating and overseeing lessors. Typically, a nation's Ministry of Finance or Central Bank is in charge of regulating and overseeing lessors. All leasing firms will be subject to specific administrative and financial standards set forth by the governing body. The ILO (2003) states that the most prevalent of these are:
1) Minimum capital requirements: Banks and other financial institutions must possess a certain level of capital. Leasing companies typically have lower capital requirements than banks.
2) Maximum debt to equity ratio: This ratio contrasts the amount of capital invested by shareholders with the amount borrowed by the lessor. This should not be more than 10:1, which means that for every unit invested by the shareholder, no more than 10 units of capital should be borrowed. After many years of experience in leasing enterprises around the world, the International Finance Corporation advised a maximum ratio of 10:1
[15] | Idhayajothi, R., & Latasri, O. T. V. (2015). A study on performance of SBI mutual funds in Tiruchirapalli district of Tamilnadu. International Journal of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences, 4(6). |
[15]
.
2.2.2. Business Size
A proxy for firm scale is used to quantify a company's size in order to reflect potential cost advantages related to economies of scale. There are conflicting results in the literature on the connection between profitability and size. Compared to smaller businesses, larger ones may profit from more investment diversity. There appears to be a positive correlation between company size and profitability, as this diversification lowers risk and economies of scale can improve operational efficiency by reducing expenses
[1] | Allen, M., Titsworth, S. and Hunt, S. K., (2008): Quantitative research in communication: Sage Publications. |
[1]
. For example, growing branch networks could result in increased operating costs, which could have a detrimental effect on profitability. Therefore, it is impossible to make a firm theoretical prediction about how company size would affect profitability
[10] | Danaei, A. and Abdi, H. (2015), The relationship between firm size and profitability indicators of sustainable capital structure of listed companies in Tehran stock exchange, Indian Journal of Fundamental and Applied Life Sciences, 5(S1), 5029-5041. |
[10]
.
2.2.3. Tax Incentives
The tax structure in many nations encourages leasing agreements. Since the lessor owns the equipment, they record the whole lease payment- principal and interest- as income. However, they also have the ability to deduct the asset's depreciation, frequently at a faster rate. The lease payments can be subtracted from the lessee's taxable income in the interim. Because the lease period is usually shorter than the equipment's useful life, the lessee can depreciate the asset more quickly than they could have if they had purchased it out ight
[8] | Casu, B. and Girardone, C., (2006): Bank competition, concentration and efficiency in the single European market; The Manchester School, 74(4), pp. 441-468. |
[8]
. Consequently, the entire tax liability related to the lease is decreased, benefiting both parties with expedited tax relief
[16] | International Finance Corporation (IFC 2009), Leasing in Development: Guidelines for Emerging Economies, Washington DC. |
[16]
. The cost of capital after taxes is impacted by leasing's impact on cash flows. Additionally, the leasing process permits the impact of the tax shield to be transferred to the best possible firm in the event that the lessor and the leaseholder have different taxation rates
[28] | Schroth, P. W. (2010). Financial leasing of equipment in the law of the United States. The American Journal of Comparative Law, 58(suppl_1), 323-352. |
[28]
. It is occasionally possible to reach an agreement on terms that benefit the lessor and the leaseholder by using leasing tax regulations.
2.2.4. Access to Funding
The opportunities that entrepreneurs can recognize are greatly influenced by the resources that are available to them. Increased resources allow for more thorough testing, which increases the likelihood of innovation (Paladino, 2007). Resource limitations, on the other hand, can spur innovation by encouraging businesses with little money to look into every alternative, including lease finance
[26] | R. Idhayajothi, O. T. V. Latasri, N. Manjula, A. Meharaj Banu and R. Malini, (2014): “A Study on Financial Performance of Ashok Leyland Limited at Chennai,” IOSR Journal of Business and Management (IOSR-JBM) 16, no. 6(I): 83-89. |
[26]
.
However, a lack of qualified managers can impede sound financial decision-making, and financial constraints can impede creativity and overall effectiveness. Accessing professional guidance on financing possibilities is another challenge for small enterprises with limited resources
[22] | Marshall, C. and Rossman, G. B., (2014): Designing qualitative research: Sage publications. |
[22]
. Furthermore, a major obstacle for small and medium-sized manufacturing companies is limited access to credit or capital, which restricts their financing options
[19] | Munene, W. W. (2014). The effect of lease financing on the financial performance of companies listed at the Nairobi securities exchange (Doctoral dissertation). |
[19]
. Businesses frequently turn to informal loans or internal savings in these situations
[4] | Berger, A. N. and Humphrey, D. B., (1997): Efficiency of financial institutions: International survey and directions for future research; European journal of operational research, 98(2), pp. 175-212. |
[4]
.
2.2.5. Availability of Facilities
Though the relationship may not be direct, there may be a correlation between the availability of water and electrical facilities to businesses and their degree of lease finance involvement. Here are some ways that these elements may affect involvement. For businesses to run effectively, access to dependable water and electrical supplies is essential. Businesses need a reliable power source to run their machinery, equipment, and other assets efficiently. Likewise, water facilities are necessary for a number of industrial procedures. Businesses are more likely to use lease financing to purchase assets that need water and electricity for operations when these services are easily accessible. In terms of operational needs, productivity and efficiency, industry-specific requirements, and cost concerns, the availability of water and power for businesses can also have a favorable impact on their lease finance practices
[3] | Alyosius, C., and Lubinda, H. (2013): A Study of the Development of Leasing Industry in Zambia: International Journal of Sciences: Basic and Applied Research. |
[3]
.
3. Materials & Methods
3.1. Research Design
In order to explain why something occurs or how and why variables are related, this study used an explanatory research design. It is frequently employed to test hypotheses and demonstrate causality. This particular research strategy was chosen because it measures the cause-and-effect relationship between variables of interest and uses statistical tools to evaluate numerical data in order to find trends and patterns.
3.2. Research Approach
This study was used a quantitative research approach to completely analyze the financial performance of the sample population (leasing finance companies) in order to explain the research findings.
3.3. Target Population of the Study
Five approved and fully functional capital goods finance companies that are formally registered and overseen by the National Bank of Ethiopia were the subject of the current study. This covers all businesses in the capital goods finance industry that have completed the lease process and received official regulatory authority recognition. The research sought to give a focused and thorough review of the financial performance of five leasing companies within the Ethiopian financial environment by limiting its coverage to this particular community.
3.4. Sampling Method
Since there aren't many lease finance companies in Ethiopia, it is possible to analyze the complete population, which would give a thorough understanding of the factors influencing the financial success of these companies. For this reason, the census approach was used in this study.
3.5. Sources & Methods of Data Collection
The study used both primary & secondary data of the lease financing in Ethiopia for the period of 2014-2023, i.e., for ten consecutive years. Primary data was collected using survey questionnaires whereas, secondary data was collected from National Bank of Ethiopia.
3.6. Model Specification
FP = F (BS, TI, AT, AF). The model is adopted from the work of
[31] | Tongc (2007): Purposive sampling as a tool for informant selection. |
[31]
.
FP=α+β1(BS)+β2(TI)+β3(AT)+β4(AF)+℮(1)
Where FP = Financial performance for the firms in the industry,
α = an intercepts, β = Coefficient of the model-variable, BS = Business size, TI = Tax incentives, AT = Asset Type, AF = Access to funding, and ℮ = error term.
5. Discussion of Regression Result
5.1. Regulatory Framework
According to the regression result of regulatory framework has a positive relationship with financial performance of lease finance companies in Ethiopia by a coefficient estimate of 0.073. This means regulatory framework is associated with a 0.073 unit increase in financial performance and has no significant effect on financial performance that is p- value 0.260 above significance level p value 0.05. As it is clearly discussed in the chapter two, in accordance to (ILO, 2003), prudential requirements for lessors are generally less strict than those for banks, because lessors are not usually allowed to attract deposits. Nevertheless, it is in the interest of shareholders as well as lessees that there are minimum prudential requirements. This helps to maintain a stable and vibrant leasing industry (ILO, 2003). The regulating authority will spell out certain financial and administrative requirements for all leasing companies, this maybe the cause why the legal framework would have no significant effect on the financial performance these companies.
5.2. Business Size
According to regression result, the business size has negative relationship with financial performance of lease finance companies in Ethiopia implying that a unit increase in business size is associated with a -0.036 unit decrease in financial performance and has no significant effect on financial performance that is p- value 0.379 above significance level p value 0.05. When compared to other empirical evidences, the size of a company is measured by a proxy for company scale to capture potential cost advantages associated with economies of scale. Existing literature presents mixed findings regarding the relationship between size and profitability. Larger companies may benefit from greater investment diversification compared to smaller ones. This diversification helps reduce risk, and economies of scale can enhance operational efficiency by lowering costs, suggesting a positive relationship between company size and profitability
[28] | Schroth, P. W. (2010). Financial leasing of equipment in the law of the United States. The American Journal of Comparative Law, 58(suppl_1), 323-352. |
[28]
. Nevertheless, expanding branch networks, for instance, may lead to higher operational expenses, potentially causing size to have a negative impact on profitability
[12] | Eugene F. Brigham, Louis C. Gapenski, Phillip R. Daves (2009), Intermediate Financial Management, Cengage south –Western. |
[12]
. Consequently, the impact of company size on profitability cannot be predicted with certainty based on theoretical grounds
[34] | World Bank (2015), SME Finance in Ethiopia: Addressing the Missing Middle Challenge. Washington, DC. |
[34]
. Thus, the current result is very consistent with other empirical evidences discussed above, by showing a negative impact on the financial performance of these lease companies.
5.3. Asset Type
According to regression result of asset type has negative relationship with financial performance of lease finance companies in Ethiopia by a coefficient of -0.152; indicating that a unit increase in asset type is associated with a 1.5% unit decrease in financial performance and has significant effect on financial performance that is p- value 0.003 less than significance level p value 0.05.
5.4. Tax Incentives
According to the regression result of tax incentive has a positive relationship with financial performance of lease finance companies in Ethiopia by a coefficient of 0.167 or 16.70%, implying that a unit increase in tax incentive is associated with a 16.70% unit increase in financial performance and has a significant effect on financial performance that is p - value 0.000 at 5% significance level. In comparison to empirical results, researchers argue that in many countries, the tax system favors leasing arrangements. The lessor, being the owner of the equipment, records the entire lease payment (both principal and interest) as income but can also deduct the asset's depreciation often at an accelerated rate. Meanwhile, the lessee can deduct the lease payments from their taxable income (ILO, 2003). Other scholars typically stress, when the lease duration is shorter than the equipment's useful life, allowing the lessee to effectively depreciate the asset faster than if they had bought it outright. As a result, both parties benefit from accelerated tax relief, leading to a reduction in the total tax liability associated with the lease (ILO, 2003). Therefore, this current study is also consistent with the theoretical and empirical evidences discussed in the previous chapter of this paper, stressing, tax incentive in case of Ethiopia has a positive and significant impact on the financial performance of the lease companies in terms of their net income a performance measurement proxy variable.
5.5. Access to Funding
According to regression result, access to funding has negative relationship with financial performance of lease finance companies in Ethiopia by a coefficient of -0.203, implying that any enhancement in access to funding is associated with a 20.30% leads to decrease in financial performance and has statistically significant effect on financial performance with a p - value 0.000 at 5% level of significance. As other sources of research findings confirmed, the availability of resources significantly influences the opportunities entrepreneurs can identify (Hoegl, Gibbert, & Mazursky, 2008). More resources enable extensive testing, boosting innovation chances (Paladino, 2007). Conversely, resource constraints can drive creativity, pushing organizations with limited funds to explore all possible options, including lease financing
[30] | Solfi, (2023) Global Leasing Report. |
[30]
. Financial limitations, however, can hinder innovation and overall performance, while a lack of skilled managers can impair effective financial decision-making
[7] | Brigham, E. F. and Houston, J. F., (2013), Fundamentals of financial management 13th edition, South-Western Cengage Learning. |
[7]
. Small businesses with limited resources also struggle to access expert advice on financing options (Nyachienga, 2012). Additionally, restricted access to funding or credit poses a significant challenge for small and medium-sized manufacturing firms, limiting their financing options
[18] | MUHARAM, H. (2018). Interdependency of Investment and Financing with Financial Constrains. Journal Transylvanian Review, 26(25). |
[18]
. In such cases, businesses often rely on internal savings or informal loans
[4] | Berger, A. N. and Humphrey, D. B., (1997): Efficiency of financial institutions: International survey and directions for future research; European journal of operational research, 98(2), pp. 175-212. |
[4]
. Therefore, the result of this research is very consistent with the theories and empirical evidences discusses, showing the lease financing companies in Ethiopia were negatively and significantly affected maybe in two reasons (1) maybe because of lack of adequate resources of funds or financing options (2) reliance on internal savings or informal loans they might acquire from other sources with huge repayments for the loans they owed. Most importantly, among the factors or variables assumed, access to funding (AF) is the only variable with a marginally significant negative effect on financial performance (p = 0.000) yet statistically significant, indicating that difficulties in accessing funding may be linked to poorer financial outcomes.