Browse

Journals By Subject

Life Sciences, Agriculture & Food
Chemistry
Medicine & Health
Materials Science
Mathematics & Physics
Electrical & Computer Science
Earth, Energy & Environment
Architecture & Civil Engineering
Education
Economics & Management
Humanities & Social Sciences
Multidisciplinary

Books

Publish Conference Abstract Books
Upcoming Conference Abstract Books
Published Conference Abstract Books
Publish Your Books
Upcoming Books
Published Books

Proceedings

Events

Events
Five Types of Conference Publications

Join

Join as Editorial Board Member
Become a Reviewer

Information

For Authors
For Reviewers
For Editors
For Conference Organizers
For Librarians
Article Processing Charges
Special Issue Guidelines
Editorial Process
Manuscript Transfers
Peer Review at SciencePG
Open Access
Copyright and License
Ethical Guidelines
Submit an Article
Research Article | | Peer-Reviewed

Bridging the Perception Gap: An Investigation into Consumer Trust and Brand Value in India's Influencer Ecosystem

Anmol Bansal*
Published in International Journal of Business and Economics Research (Volume 14, Issue 5)
Received: 12 September 2025     Accepted: 26 September 2025     Published: 27 October 2025
Views:       Downloads:
Download PDF
Abstract

This research investigates the complex dynamics of the influencer marketing ecosystem in India, focusing on the alignment and divergence between consumer trust, influencer strategies, and brand expectations. Through a quantitative analysis of 250 respondents, comprising 239 consumers and 21 influencers, this study examines the critical factors that shape audience perception, purchasing behavior, and platform engagement. The findings reveal a significant disconnect between the values prioritized by consumers and the metrics valued by brands. Consumers predicate their trust on perceived authenticity, personal connection, and relatable content, whereas brands are perceived to prioritize performance, reach, and content quality defined by engagement metrics. This core conflict is the primary driver of trust, particularly when content becomes overly commercialized or scripted. The study confirms a strong inverse correlation between consumer age and susceptibility to influencer persuasion, with younger demographics being most receptive. A notable "platform generation gap" is identified, with YouTube and Instagram showing universal appeal, while Facebook and X (formerly Twitter) exhibit highly age-segregated user bases. Analysis of purchasing behavior indicates that influencer recommendations are most effective for lifestyle-oriented categories such as fashion, electronics, and beauty, which are conducive to visual demonstration. Ultimately, this paper argues that the long-term sustainability of influencer marketing depends on bridging the gap between consumer expectations and creator strategies. It concludes that a strategic shift towards prioritizing authenticity over purely performance-based metrics, coupled with data-informed, age-tailored platform selection, is essential for maintaining audience trust and ensuring the continued efficacy of this marketing channel.

Published in International Journal of Business and Economics Research (Volume 14, Issue 5)
DOI 10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12
Page(s) 194-210
Creative Commons

This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, provided the original work is properly cited.

Copyright

Copyright © The Author(s), 2025. Published by Science Publishing Group
Previous article
Keywords

Influencer Marketing, Consumer Trust, Authenticity, Digital Advertising, Social Media Engagement, Brand Perception, Creator Economy, India

1. Introduction
In the rapidly evolving digital ecosystem of India, the strategies of digital marketing and social media branding are undergoing a profound, structural transformation. This shift is primarily driven by the ascendancy of influencer marketing, which has matured from a niche tactic to a central pillar of modern brand communication. As India’s digital population expands and the creator economy flourishes, this new approach has fundamentally redefined the relationship between brands and consumers. With the Indian influencer market projected to reach a valuation of over ₹4,500 crore in 2025, driven by a 25% annual growth, its impact is both significant and measurable
[1]
.
The confluence of digital technology, widespread internet access, and the proliferation of social media platforms has fundamentally reshaped the contemporary marketing landscape
[2]
. In this new paradigm, traditional advertising models, which rely on mass media and a unidirectional flow of information, are increasingly being supplanted by a more nuanced and interactive strategy. This shift is particularly pronounced in India, where a burgeoning digital population and a dynamic creator economy have provided fertile ground for this new form of brand communication. The Indian influencer marketing industry, a market valued at over $400 million in 2024, is not merely a trend but a transformative force reshaping the core principles of digital marketing and social media branding
[3]
.
Influencer marketing has restructured these domains by re-establishing a crucial element of consumer behavior: trust. It moves beyond the impersonal, intrusive nature of conventional advertisements and leverages the authentic, often relatable voice of a creator to forge meaningful connections with its audience. This strategic evolution has enabled brands to transcend a simple follower-count metric and instead focus on a deeper, more targeted engagement with niche communities. From the expansive reach of mega-influencers to the high-engagement authority of micro and nano-influencers, this ecosystem has empowered brands to tell compelling stories that resonate on a personal level. It has decentralized brand messaging, empowering individuals—from celebrated macro-influencers to highly specialized nano-influencers—to become credible conduits of information
[4]
. This phenomenon has shifted the focus of digital marketing from broad reach to deep engagement, and from generic content to hyper-localized, vernacular storytelling.
The academic discourse surrounding influencer marketing highlights its departure from conventional advertising, primarily through its reliance on social influence theory and the concept of source credibility. As noted by authors such as Lou and Yuan (2019), consumers perceive influencers as more authentic and trustworthy than traditional celebrities or brand-owned media. This credibility is a cornerstone of the influencer-follower relationship, which is often characterized by a parasocial interaction where followers feel a personal connection to the influencer. This perceived authenticity is a critical factor in driving consumer trust and, subsequently, purchase intent
[5]
.
A key theme in the literature is the strategic differentiation between various influencer tiers. While macro-influencers and celebrities offer a wide reach and brand visibility, research suggests that micro-influencers (with smaller but more engaged followings) often yield higher engagement rates and are perceived as more relatable and trustworthy
[6]
. This focus on niche, authentic voices has enabled brands to decentralize their messaging and target specific communities with greater precision and cost-effectiveness. In the Indian context, this is further amplified by the rise of vernacular content. Studies indicate that campaigns delivered in local languages and with culturally relevant imagery resonate more deeply with regional audiences, building stronger emotional connections and enhancing brand recall
[7]
. This move toward hyper-local and vernacular storytelling is a direct response to India's vast linguistic diversity and is transforming how brands approach market penetration, particularly in Tier-2 and Tier-3 cities
[8]
.
The literature also points to a fundamental shift in marketing metrics. The focus has moved from vanity metrics like follower count to more tangible outcomes such as engagement rate, conversions, and return on investment (ROI). Data from recent industry reports and academic studies reveal that influencers are a significant driver of product discovery and purchasing decisions in India, particularly among younger demographics such as Gen Z and Millennials
[9]
. This body of work collectively positions influencer marketing not as a supplement to digital advertising but as a paradigm shift that leverages personal relationships and community-driven content to drive measurable business results.
Beyond these foundational concepts, recent research highlights several evolving trends that further solidify influencer marketing's role in India. The industry is moving away from transactional, one-off collaborations toward long-term partnerships, where influencers become genuine brand ambassadors. This strategy, as noted by research from MediaBrief, is favored by a significant number of brands in high-consideration sectors like automotive and e-commerce, as it fosters deeper audience trust and sustained brand recall
[10]
. Furthermore, the role of ethical standards and transparency has become a central point of discussion. The introduction of guidelines by bodies like the Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI) and the Indian Influencer Governing Council (IIGC) underscores the industry’s push for accountability. These regulations mandate clear disclosures for sponsored content, a critical step toward combating consumer skepticism and maintaining the credibility that is the very basis of influencer marketing
[11]
.
Recent studies also highlight how different platforms and consumer demographics are shaping the influencer marketing landscape. Instagram remains the dominant platform for brand collaborations, but the growth of short-form video platforms like Moj and YouTube Shorts has introduced new dynamics
[12]
. These platforms are particularly effective for driving quick brand visibility and are preferred for entertainment-focused content, while YouTube and long-form content are often favored for in-depth product reviews and educational content, which is key for high-involvement purchases
[13]
.
Furthermore, research on consumer behavior reveals distinct patterns across different demographics in India. A study on consumers in Uttar Pradesh, for example, found that while urban audiences are drawn to aspirational content, rural consumers place a higher value on authenticity, practicality, and local relevance in influencer-driven content
[14]
. This underscores the need for brands to adopt highly tailored and regionalized strategies. The influence of influencers is particularly strong among young Indian adults aged 18-35, who spend a significant amount of time on social media and are more likely to make purchasing decisions based on influencer recommendations
[15]
. This body of work collectively positions influencer marketing not as a simple supplement to digital advertising, but as a paradigm shift that leverages personal relationships, community-driven content, and technological innovation to drive measurable business results across diverse consumer segments.
Finally, the literature points to a growing integration of advanced technology. Research indicates that AI and machine learning are increasingly being used to enhance campaign effectiveness by automating tasks like influencer identification, detecting fraudulent followers, and performing real-time sentiment analysis
[16]
. This data-driven approach allows for more precise audience targeting and optimized content strategies, ensuring that marketing efforts are both creative and results-oriented. The rise of creator-led brands, where influencers leverage their built-in audience and personal brand equity to launch their own products, also signifies a major evolution from content to commerce, transforming influencers into full-fledged entrepreneurs and highlighting the maturity of the Indian creator economy
[17]
.
The impact of influencer marketing is not uniform across all sectors. The literature presents several case studies illustrating how different industries in India have adapted these strategies to their specific needs. In the fashion and beauty industries, for instance, influencers are moving beyond simple product showcases to more intimate storytelling through formats like "Get Ready With Me" videos. Brands like Mamaearth and L'Oréal have leveraged influencers to promote authenticity and inclusivity, building communities around shared values rather than just products
[18, 19]
. This content evolution is intrinsically linked to the rise of social commerce, which is transforming social media platforms into direct sales channels. With the Indian social commerce market projected to reach $16-20 billion by 2025, influencers are no longer just endorsers but crucial sales agents. Platforms are facilitating this by integrating features such as shoppable reels, live shopping events, and in-app affiliate links, allowing consumers to move seamlessly from product discovery to purchase within a single feed
[20]
. This trend highlights a fundamental shift in the marketing funnel, where the line between content and commerce is increasingly blurred, and the influencer serves as the direct link to the final transaction.
This paper will critically analyze how this phenomenon has redefined brand-consumer relationships, driven the creation of new content formats, and established a data-driven framework for social media branding in India, thereby demonstrating its indispensable role in the country's modern commercial and cultural narrative.
2. Methodology
The present study adopts a quantitative research design to systematically investigate the impact of influencer marketing on digital marketing and social media branding in India. The primary objective is to collect empirical data to measure the relationship between key variables such as age, gender, influencer authenticity, platform choice, content type, and consumer purchase intent, etc.
2.1. Data Collection
Primary data was collected through a structured online questionnaire developed on Google Forms. The survey was designed to gather insights into respondents' social media habits, their engagement with influencers, and the influence of influencer-generated content on their purchasing decisions. The questionnaire used a mix of multiple-choice and Likert-scale questions to measure perceptions of influencer credibility, brand trust, and the effectiveness of various content formats. The consumer perspective was prioritized because this research aimed to understand the impact and reception of influencer marketing from the audience's viewpoint, reflecting the real-world scenario where audiences vastly outnumber creators. Contextual insights from creators were retained to provide a comparative understanding of their intentions and perceptions regarding effective strategies, highlighting potential misalignments with consumer expectations.
2.2. Sampling Strategy
The sampling technique employed was purposive sampling. This approach was chosen for its practicality, appropriateness, and efficiency in reaching a large number of active social media users, who are the target population for this study. The survey was distributed through various digital channels, including social media platforms, online forums, and email lists, to ensure a diverse pool of respondents. The sample focused on Indian consumers of various age groups, as this demographic is most heavily engaged with influencer marketing, as noted in the literature review. The final sample size consisted of 250 valid responses.
2.3. Data Analysis
The collected data were exported and analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistical methods. Descriptive statistics, including frequencies and percentages, were used to summarize the demographic profile of the respondents and their general social media behavior.
3. Results and Discussions
3.1. Demographic Profile of Survey Respondents
This study was conducted with a total sample of 250 respondents, segmented into two primary cohorts: consumers (n=239) and influencers (n=21). This composition intentionally weights the dataset towards the consumer perspective, with this group constituting 95.6% of the total sample. The inclusion of the influencer cohort (4.4%) serves to provide contextual insights from the creator's viewpoint without skewing the primary research focus. The demographic profile of the sample is predominantly skewed towards younger, urban populations. A significant majority of participants fall into the 18-24 age bracket (55.6%), with the 25-34 age group representing the next largest segment (24.4%) (Figure 1). Collectively, these two groups constitute 80% of the total respondents. As a result, the findings and conclusions presented in this research are most reflective of the perspectives and digital behaviors of urban youth.
The gender distribution across the sample was notably balanced. Approximately one-third (33%) of the respondents in both the consumer and influencer cohorts were female. This equitable gender representation provides a stable baseline for analysis, ensuring that any observed gender-specific trends are likely attributable to genuine behavioral differences rather than a bias introduced during sampling. Given the intentional imbalance in the sample sizes of the two cohorts, the primary analytical focus of this study is on consumer reception. This methodological approach is designed to mirror the real-world digital ecosystem, where the audience vastly outnumbers content creators. The research, therefore, prioritizes a deep understanding of audience attitudes and trust drivers. While the influencer data provides a valuable comparative lens, the study's core objective is to investigate consumer perception rather than creator intention (Figure 2).
Figure 1. Age distribution of Consumer vs Influencers in each age group within in each cohort of 250 survey participants.
Figure 2. The regional distribution of the survey participants in terms of metro cities and non-metro cities.
3.2. The Moderating Effect of Age on Influencer Susceptibility
A primary finding of this study is the significant role of age as a moderating variable in determining the efficacy of influencer marketing. The data reveals a distinct inverse correlation between the age of a consumer and their susceptibility to persuasion by influencers. As age increases, the direct impact of influencer endorsements on purchasing decisions and brand perception demonstrably declines. This trend is most pronounced within the teenage demographic, which exhibited the highest degree of impressionability. According to the data, 100% of teenage respondents reported being influenced to purchase products recommended by online creators. This suggests that opinions are fundamentally shaped by the content consumed on social media platforms, making them highly receptive to influencer-led campaigns.
Conversely, the challenge of influencing consumer opinion and behavior increases linearly with age. Older demographics appear to exhibit a higher degree of skepticism towards influencer endorsements or demonstrate lower overall engagement with such content. This suggests a developed resistance to persuasion, requiring more than a simple recommendation to alter established brand loyalties or opinions. The clear demarcation in response across age groups carries significant strategic implications (Figure 3 and Figure 4). A monolithic, 'one-size-fits-all' approach to influencer marketing is evidently ineffective. The findings strongly advocate for age-tailored strategies:
For Younger Audiences (Teens & Young Adults): Campaigns can be successfully built around trend-focused, peer-driven narratives that leverage the high level of trust and influence creators hold within these circles.
For Older Audiences (30+): Reaching this demographic requires a shift in focus from trendiness to trustworthiness. Marketing strategies should be centered on substantive information, authentic expertise, and transparent endorsements that build credibility, as this group is less likely to be swayed by popularity alone.
Figure 3. Percentage of likelihood of purchase done by various participants of various age groups based on influencer suggestions.
Figure 4. This graph shows how influencer are shaping the brand opinion among various age group.
3.3. The Influence of Geographic Context on Reception and Platform Preference
The geographic setting of the audience serves as a critical mediator in the reception of influencer marketing. Analysis reveals distinct patterns in platform usage and consumer attitudes when comparing metropolitan and non-metropolitan populations, underscoring the need for geographically localized campaign strategies (Figure 5).
Figure 5. The usage of various social media platforms in metro-and non-metro cities and their comparison.
3.3.1. Platform Dominance and Regional Divergence
While Instagram and YouTube demonstrate universal popularity, holding dominant positions as the preferred platforms in both metro and non-metro regions, a notable divergence occurs in the broader digital landscape. Consumers in metropolitan areas exhibit more diversified media consumption habits, actively engaging with a wider array of platforms, including Facebook, LinkedIn, and X. This suggests that marketers targeting urban audiences can leverage a multi-platform strategy, whereas campaigns for non-metro regions might achieve a higher return on investment by concentrating efforts on Instagram and YouTube (Figure 6).
Figure 6. This graph shows the effectiveness perceived by various residents of metro and non-metro cities of Influencer marketing and traditional ads.
3.3.2. Perceptions of Authenticity: Influencer Marketing vs. Traditional Advertising
A significant majority of respondents, particularly those in metropolitan areas, perceive influencer marketing as more personal and convincing than traditional advertising methods like television or newspaper ads. This preference appears to be linked to the high saturation of conventional advertising in urban environments, which leads consumers to view influencer endorsements as a more authentic and refreshing alternative. However, this sentiment is not universal. A segment of the audience remains unconvinced, viewing influencer marketing as fundamentally indistinct from traditional ads and questioning the genuineness of sponsored endorsements. This skepticism is particularly pronounced in non-metropolitan areas, where the perceived "authenticity gap" is wider. Respondents in these regions are more likely to equate influencer marketing with celebrity endorsements on television, suggesting that the perception of it being "just for the sake of it" is a more significant barrier to overcome outside of major urban centers.
3.4. Platforms as Arenas of Reach and Exposure
The selection of a social media platform is a critical determinant of a campaign's reach and its ability to connect with the intended audience (Figure 7). The data indicates a complex digital landscape where consumer attention is fragmented across various platforms, often dictated by demographic factors like age and professional status. This creates a disconnect between where consumers spend their time and where influencers might focus their content, necessitating a nuanced platform strategy (Figure 8).
Figure 7. The Graph shows the domination of the various social media platforms in terms of everyday usage among all the participants.
Figure 8. Demarcation of usage of social media platforms among all the age-groups.
3.4.1. The Universal Dominance of YouTube and Instagram
YouTube and Instagram emerge as the foundational pillars of content consumption across all age demographics. Their universal popularity, from teenagers to individuals in their 40s, establishes them as the primary digital arenas for broad-spectrum influencer marketing. Their consistent usage across the sample solidifies their role as the most reliable platforms for campaigns targeting a wide and varied audience.
3.4.2. The Platform Generation Gap: Facebook and X
A distinct "platform generation gap" is evident in the usage patterns of Facebook and X. Facebook's user base in this study is heavily concentrated among older adults (35 and above), with its presence being virtually negligible among younger millennials and Gen Z respondents. This strongly suggests an exodus of younger demographics from the platform, rendering it less effective for campaigns targeting that cohort. X exhibits the inverse trend. Its engagement is primarily driven by a younger demographic, likely college-aged users, with minimal to no reported usage among older participants. This bifurcation highlights a clear generational divide, where platform choice itself is a key demographic indicator.
3.4.3. The Emergence of Niche and Professional Platforms: The Case of LinkedIn
The notable ranking of LinkedIn among the most-used platforms indicates that the scope of influencer marketing in India is expanding beyond conventional lifestyle and entertainment verticals. The presence of a significant user base on a career-oriented platform suggests that a substantial portion of the respondents are professionals or students actively seeking professional and educational content. This finding confirms that influencer marketing has successfully penetrated professional networking spaces, creating viable opportunities for B2B and career-focused campaigns.
3.5. The Creator Perspective: Platform Selection and Content Strategy
From the creator's standpoint, platform selection is a strategic decision balancing audience reach with content format. The data reveals both a strong alignment with consumer habits on major platforms and potential untapped opportunities on others (Figure 9).
3.5.1. Alignment and Misalignment in Platform Choice
Primary Alignment: A healthy and direct alignment is observed on Instagram and YouTube. Both platforms are ranked highly for content creation by influencers and for content consumption by consumers. This synergy indicates that creator efforts on these platforms are well-placed, directly reaching an active and engaged user base.
Generational Misalignment (Facebook): While a number of influencers continue to utilize Facebook as a content outlet, the consumer data reveals a significant drop-off in engagement among younger demographics. This creates a potential misalignment where creator effort may not yield proportional returns from key target segments like Gen Z and younger millennials.
Untapped Opportunity (LinkedIn): A notable mismatch exists for LinkedIn. Despite consumers ranking it as a frequently used platform, it appears to be leveraged by only a niche segment of influencers. This gap between high consumer presence and low creator saturation implies a significant, and likely untapped, opportunity for influencers specializing in professional, educational, or B2B content.
Figure 9. Shows the usage of social media platforms for posting content among influencers.
3.5.2. Platform-Specific Content Specialization
The distribution of content categories across platforms demonstrates that creators strategically tailor their content to fit the inherent strengths of each platform's format and audience expectations.
Visual-Centric Platforms: Instagram and, to a lesser extent, Facebook, are the primary hubs for visually-rich and aspirational content, particularly within the Fashion and Lifestyle verticals. Their image and short-form video formats are ideally suited for this type of aesthetic-driven content.
Entertainment-Focused Platforms: YouTube has solidified its position as the undisputed powerhouse for Entertainment. Its long-form video format is the preferred medium for a wide range of entertainment content, from comedic sketches to informative deep dives.
3.5.3. The Ubiquity of Entertainment Content
While some content categories are platform-specific, Entertainment serves as a common, unifying thread across the digital landscape. It is a dominant category on nearly every surveyed social platform, including Instagram, YouTube, and X. The primary exception is purpose-driven platforms like Medium, which are explicitly oriented toward technical or educational blogging. This widespread presence indicates that an element of entertainment is a core expectation for audiences, regardless of the platform they are using.
3.6. Analysis of Product Categories and Content Niches
3.6.1. Consumer Purchasing Behavior Driven by Influencer Recommendations
Figure 10. The pie chart shows the various categories of products that are used by people by are influenced by influencers.
The data obtained in this study confirms that consumer purchasing decisions influenced by social media are highly concentrated within a few key product categories (Figure 10). An analysis of self-reported purchases reveals a clear hierarchy:
1) Fashion & Apparel
2) Electronics & Gadgets
3) Food & Beverages
4) Beauty & Skincare
These top four categories are distinguished by their broad consumer appeal, aligning with general lifestyle needs and interests. Their success in the influencer marketing space can be attributed to their suitability for visual demonstration. Tactics such as unboxing videos, try-on hauls, and before-and-after showcases are particularly effective in these sectors, providing the visual proof that drives conversions. This alignment with fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) and aspirational lifestyle products underscores a key driver of the creator economy.
Furthermore, an analysis of the teenage demographic reveals a distinct preference for digital products and fitness-related items. This suggests a pattern of aspiration-driven consumption, heavily influenced by prevailing trends in gaming culture, digital identity formation, and social media-driven body image standards (Figure 11).
Figure 11. Distribution of influencer content niches.
3.6.2. Influencer Content Specialization and Market Dynamics
The content niches chosen by creators largely mirror consumer purchasing trends, while also highlighting different strategic approaches to audience engagement (Figure 12 and Figure 13).
Broad-Appeal Niches: Fashion and Lifestyle stands out as the most common content category, a direct response to the large addressable market and high purchase intent. This is closely followed by Entertainment, which serves a dual purpose. It caters to the universal consumer demand for leisure and light content, and its broad, non-specific nature provides creators with the flexibility to market a wide array of products without being constrained by a narrow niche.
Emerging High-Growth Niches: The Education sector is experiencing a significant boom within the creator industry. This trend reflects a shift in consumer behavior, where audiences increasingly turn to online creators for knowledge, skills, and inspiration. In this context, influencers are perceived not merely as marketers but as sources of valuable information and experience.
Specialized Niche Markets: Categories such as fitness, digital goods, and specialized educational tools appeal to narrower but often more loyal markets. Influencers operating in these spaces typically function as domain experts rather than generalist entertainers. Their value proposition is built on credibility and specialized knowledge, fostering a high-trust relationship with their audience.
Figure 12. Graph shows the top drivers of trust in influencer recommendations to consumers.
Figure 13. This shows the brand selection criteria in influencer partnerships.
3.7. The Dynamics of Consumer Trust, Attention, and Brand Perception
The efficacy of influencer marketing is fundamentally dependent on the influencer's ability to build and maintain trust with their audience. This section analyzes the key determinants that govern why consumers choose to believe or disregard influencer endorsements, revealing a complex interplay between authenticity, commercial interests, and audience perception.
3.7.1. Trust & Authenticity vs. Performance & Quality
A foundational disconnect exists between the values prioritized by consumers and those perceived to be valued by brands and influencers.
Consumer Perspective: Consumer trust is primarily contingent upon the perceived authenticity of the content and the influencer's genuine personal experience with a product. Endorsements that appear scripted, impersonal, or overly commercialized are actively rejected. For consumers, "quality" is defined by relatability and honesty.
Influencer/Brand Perspective: Conversely, influencers believe that brands prioritize tangible performance metrics, such as production quality and engagement rates (likes, shares, comments), as the primary indicators of a campaign's success. Here, "quality" is defined by content performance.
While both sides agree on the importance of "quality and authenticity," their definitions diverge significantly, creating a potential tension between creating relatable content and meeting brand KPIs.
Figure 14. This gives an analysis of influencer marketing vs. traditional Advertising.
3.7.2. Attention & Engagement Amidst Advertisement Fatigue
The study highlights how influencer marketing navigates the challenge of consumer Ad fatigue (Figure 14).
Consumer Perspective: Consumers report experiencing significant fatigue with traditional advertising. Influencer-driven ads are only effective at breaking through this noise when they are presented by a familiar and trusted creator in a manner that feels natural and contextually appropriate.
Influencer Perspective: Influencers correctly identify their core value proposition to brands as the ability to drive higher engagement and outperform traditional advertising.
This confirms the influencer's role in capturing attention, but with a critical caveat: this advantage is sustained only as long as the content avoids overt commercialism and maintains an authentic feel (Figure 15).
Figure 15. Shows the reasons brands consider the influencer for selling their products.
3.7.3. The Peril of Commercialization: Passion vs. Profit
The motivation behind an influencer's content is a key factor in how it is received by the audience (Figure 16).
Consumer Perspective: Audience trust diminishes when an influencer promotes an excessive number of products or when their delivery sounds disingenuous and overly scripted. This perception of "selling out" is a primary reason for disengagement.
Influencer Perspective: The data reveals that influencers are most often motivated by intrinsic factors like creative expression and personal branding. Financial incentives, while present, rank lower on their list of primary drivers.
This passion-driven motivation is precisely what builds the authentic connection that consumers crave. However, the paradox is that as an influencer's success leads to more brand partnerships, the risk of over-commercialization increases, potentially eroding the very authenticity that built their audience in the first place (Figure 17).
Figure 16. The reason of core drivers of influencer for content creation.
Figure 17. Impact of digital marketing on trust.
3.7.4. The Aligned Role in Building Brand Trust
Despite differing perspectives on certain metrics, both consumers and influencers are largely in agreement regarding the role of influencer marketing in building brand trust.
Consumer Perspective: Consumers already perceive influencer marketing as a more personal and convincing communication channel compared to traditional corporate advertising.
Influencer Perspective: Influencers believe they play a moderate to high role in building this trust, acknowledging their impact without typically overstating it.
This alignment confirms that the trust-building potential of influencer marketing is recognized by both sides. The key challenge for the ecosystem is to preserve this advantage by prioritizing and protecting creator authenticity, even as brands continue to focus on measurable performance outcomes.
3.8. Bridging the Gap Between Consumer Trust and Influencer Strategy
The long-term viability of the creator economy depends on reconciling the divergent expectations and strategies of consumers, influencers, and brands. The analysis reveals critical gaps in perception and priority that must be addressed to maintain the trust and attention of the audience.
3.8.1. The Central Conflict: What Consumers Trust vs. What Brands Value
The most significant chasm lies in the differing definitions of value. While consumers grant trust based on authenticity, personal connection, and perceived expertise, brands often prioritize metrics like popularity, reach, and performance consistency. This fundamental misalignment is the primary source of friction within the ecosystem. When brand KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) compel creators to produce content that feels overly scripted or inauthentic, it directly undermines the foundation of consumer trust. The challenge, therefore, is to find a strategic middle ground where authentic, relatable content can also deliver measurable and satisfactory results for brand partners (Figure 18).
The data reveals some significant misalignments between what consumers trust and what brands prioritize:
1) Biggest Disconnect (Personal Connection): The most striking difference is in Personal Connection. It is the second most important factor for consumers at 33%, but it ranks near the bottom for brands at only 9%. This suggests brands may be underestimating the power of genuine connection in building consumer trust.
2) Brand vs. Consumer Priorities: Brands place a very high value on Consistency & Performance (26%), making it their second-highest priority. Consumers, however, rank this theme near the bottom (5%), indicating that consistent posting or brand performance is not a primary driver of trust for them.
3) Area of Agreement (Authenticity): Both groups agree on the importance of Authenticity & Quality, with it being the top factor for both consumers (37%) and brands (32%). This is the area of strongest alignment.
4) Minor Differences: Brands value Popularity & Reach (12% vs. 6%) and Brand Association (9% vs. 2%) more than consumers do. Conversely, consumers place a higher value on Expertise & Niche (18% vs. 12%) than brands.
5) The data shows a significant disconnect between where consumers spend their time and where creators focus their efforts.
6) Biggest Mismatch (YouTube): YouTube represents the largest missed opportunity. It's the second most-used platform by consumers (30%), but it ranks low in creation focus for influencers (15%). This suggests a large, potentially underserved audience on the platform.
7) Best Alignment (Instagram): Instagram is the most closely aligned platform. It is the top platform for both consumer usage (56%) and influencer creation (44%). While there's still a gap, it's where audience and creator activity are most in sync.
8) Creator Over-Focus (Facebook & LinkedIn): Facebook and LinkedIn show an opposite trend. Influencers are creating content there (15% and 13%, respectively) at a much higher rate than consumers are using them (2% and 6%). This indicates that creator effort may be disproportionately high on platforms with lower consumer engagement.
3.8.2. The Strategic Mismatch: Consumer Usage vs. Influencer Creation by Platform
As previously discussed, there are notable mismatches between the platforms where consumers spend their time and where influencers concentrate their creative efforts. A slopegraph analysis comparing consumer usage against influencer creation would clearly illustrate these divergences—for example, the high consumer presence on LinkedIn versus its relatively low usage by creators. Bridging this gap requires a more data-informed approach to platform strategy, encouraging creators and brands to identify and capitalize on these untapped opportunities where an engaged audience already exists.
3.8.3. The Primary Drivers of Ad Ignorance and Trust Erosion
The research clearly identifies the principal reasons why influencer-led advertisements are ignored. These are not failures of the marketing channel itself, but rather failures in execution that violate the audience's core expectations.
Lack of Perceived Authenticity: The single most cited reason for ignoring an influencer ad is the belief that the content is scripted and lacks genuineness. Consumers are adept at identifying endorsements that do not align with the creator's established persona or feel like a forced commercial insertion rather than a natural recommendation.
Over-Commercialization: When an influencer promotes too many products in quick succession, their credibility diminishes. The audience begins to perceive the creator's motivation as purely financial, concluding that the primary goal is to "just make money" rather than to provide genuine, useful recommendations. This perception severs the personal connection and erodes the follower's trust.
Ultimately, bridging these gaps requires a strategic realignment. Influencers and brands must recognize that authenticity is not merely a buzzword but the core asset upon which the entire value exchange is built. Prioritizing long-term trust over short-term performance metrics is essential for sustaining audience engagement and ensuring the continued effectiveness of influencer marketing (Figure 18).
Figure 18. The analysis of influencer marketing w. r. t to consumers and influencers.
3.9. Future Outlook: A Comparative Analysis of Consumer and Influencer Expectations
As the influencer marketing landscape matures, expectations regarding its future trajectory diverge, revealing different perspectives on its sustainability, potential for growth, and the role of regulation.
3.9.1. The Consumer Perspective: Cautious Optimism
The majority of consumers hold a positive outlook on the future of influencer marketing. This group is generally split into two beliefs:
1) That the industry will sustain its current peak, solidifying its role as a significant, albeit limited, component within a company's broader marketing strategy.
2) That it will continue to grow and evolve, eventually becoming a dominant and mainstream form of marketing.
However, this optimism is not universal. A notable segment of consumers remains skeptical, viewing the current landscape as an "early stage of uncertainty." This cohort posits that the industry may be nearing a saturation point, which could lead to a decline in its importance and a reduced role in the marketing mix as audiences become increasingly fatigued or distrustful.
3.9.2. The Influencer Perspective: A Belief in Regulated Growth
Influencers, from their position within the industry, are predominantly bullish on its future. A significant majority believe that influencer marketing is still in its nascent stages and is poised for substantial growth. Crucially, they anticipate that the industry will become more regulated over time. They view this potential for oversight not as a hindrance, but as a necessary step to build greater trust and transparency with consumers, which in turn will fuel its evolution into a dominant marketing channel.
Despite this prevailing confidence, a minority of influencers share the skepticism expressed by some consumers. This smaller group acknowledges the possibility that the industry's role could become more limited or even decline in the future, suggesting an awareness of the challenges related to market saturation and maintaining authenticity.
In summary, while both groups acknowledge a degree of uncertainty, influencers are generally more confident in the long-term growth of the industry, pinning their hopes on future regulation to solidify its legitimacy. Consumers, while largely positive, are more divided, with a significant portion remaining unconvinced of its long-term dominance.
4. Conclusion
Influencer marketing has fundamentally reshaped the digital branding landscape in India, though its efficacy is significantly moderated by demographic and geographic factors. The research confirms that younger consumers, particularly Gen Z and teenagers, are highly susceptible to purchasing products recommended by social media influencers. Their opinions and consumer behaviors are increasingly shaped by their online content consumption, a stark contrast to older, more discerning adults who often view such promotions with a skepticism similar to that reserved for traditional advertisements. This study also identifies a regional divide; metropolitan audiences are more receptive to influencer-driven campaigns as an alternative to oversaturated traditional media, while non-metropolitan audiences express greater caution and question the authenticity of endorsements. Despite these pockets of skepticism, the prevailing sentiment across the sample is that influencer marketing feels more personal, relatable, and trustworthy than classical advertising channels, a perception that has driven tangible shifts in consumer behavior. Instagram and YouTube have emerged as the dominant platforms for influencer outreach in India, engaging a broad demographic spectrum. Instagram is particularly favored by youth, while YouTube enjoys universal appeal. In contrast, Facebook's usage is largely confined to older adults, highlighting a clear generational divide in platform preference. The peer-style communication on these platforms allows brands to foster connections that traditional ads cannot. Respondents widely reported that influencer endorsements capture their attention more effectively than brand-generated content, as they are perceived as authentic narratives rather than overt promotions. This impact is most pronounced in visually driven and lifestyle-oriented categories, with fashion, electronics, food & beverages, and beauty/skincare being the sectors most influenced by creators.
5. Implications & Future Aspects
5.1. Implications for Business Strategy
The findings indicate that the Indian market is highly segmented, necessitating tailored strategies for different demographics, regions, and platforms.
1) Audience Segmentation: To engage Gen Z and millennials, brands should focus on Instagram and YouTube with interactive, visual content. For older audiences, a hybrid approach combining niche experts (e.g., in finance, health) with traditional channels may be more effective.
2) Geographic Customization: In metro areas, influencer campaigns can effectively cut through ad fatigue. In non-metro and rural regions, leveraging regional and micro-influencers is crucial for building trust and authenticity.
3) Authenticity as a Cornerstone: Authenticity is the most critical asset. Brands must move away from rigidly scripted promotions and grant influencers the creative freedom to act as genuine storytellers. Selecting influencers whose values align with the brand and ensuring transparency in partnerships are paramount.
4) Strategic Influencer Selection: The focus must shift from partnering with macro-influencers based solely on follower count to a more strategic approach centered on a network of micro and nano-influencers. These creators are perceived as more authentic and relatable, which this research confirms are crucial traits for building trust and driving impact.
5) Rethinking Measurement: A new framework for measuring success is needed, one that moves beyond immediate sales to include long-term metrics such as brand recall, sentiment, and image. Influencers should be treated as long-term brand ambassadors, not short-term ad channels.
5.2. Implications for Academic Research
This study contributes to the academic literature in several key areas:
1) It provides a much-needed Indian perspective to the field of influencer marketing, which has been predominantly dominated by Western-centric studies.
2) It empirically confirms generational differences in susceptibility, reinforcing existing theories on authenticity and trust as key drivers of influencer impact.
3) It introduces regional and cultural factors as underexplored but significant variables in determining influencer effectiveness.
4) By including both consumer and influencer perspectives, it offers a more holistic view of the creator ecosystem, highlighting the gaps in perception and priority between stakeholders.
6. Limitations and Future Prospects
6.1. Limitations of the Current Study
The cross-sectional "point-in-time" design of this research limits its ability to examine long-term trends in consumer behavior. Furthermore, the sample, while informative, lacks deep diversity across India's vast linguistic, cultural, and social landscape, underscoring the need for more in-depth analyses of "consumer heterogeneity."
6.2. Directions for Future Research
This study opens several avenues for future academic exploration:
1) Longitudinal Studies: Future research should track consumer cohorts over extended periods to measure the long-term value of influencer marketing on metrics like brand awareness and loyalty, moving beyond immediate sales.
2) Cultural and Regional Nuances: There is a significant opportunity to move beyond the simple metro/non-metro divide. Studies should explore how influencer marketing functions in different linguistic or regional contexts within India, examining how localized content affects trust and purchase intent.
3) Platform-Specific Analysis: A comparative analysis is needed to understand how features unique to each platform (e.g., Instagram Reels, YouTube Shorts, live streaming) shape user engagement. The rise of AI and virtual influencers also presents a novel area for investigation.
4) Ethical and Sustainability Issues: There is broad scope to explore the long-term ethical implications of the industry. Future work could examine how repeated exposure to sponsored content affects brand credibility, or how influencers navigate the balance between monetization and authenticity. Key issues for the sustainability of the ecosystem, such as influencer burnout, content saturation, and consumer ad fatigue, warrant dedicated academic focus. Finally, research could examine whether media literacy education can mitigate the susceptibility of vulnerable audiences, such as teenagers, to influencer persuasion.
Abbreviations

AI

Artificial Intelligence

B2B

Business-to-Business

FMCG

Fast-Moving Consumer Goods

Gen Z

Generation Z

KPI

Key Performance Indicator

ROI

Return on Investment
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank all the survey participants for their contribution to my research.
Author Contributions
Anmol Bansal is the sole author. The author read and approved the final manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest
There is no conflict of interest.
References
[1] Bharucha, J., 2018. Social network use and youth well-being: a study in India. Safer Communities, 17(2), pp. 119-131.
[2] Chakola, A., 2022. The Impact of Social Media Influencer on the Buying Behaviour of Gen Z in India (Doctoral dissertation, Dublin, National College of Ireland).
[3] Chaudhary, P., & Gupta, P. (2022). Impact of social media influencers on purchase intention of beauty products: The mediating role of customer trust. Journal of Marketing and Consumer Research, 84, 1-13.

https://doi.org/10.7176/JMCR/84-01

[4] De Veirman, M., Cauberghe, V., & Hudders, L. (2017). Marketing through Instagram influencers: The impact of number of followers and product divergence on brand attitude. International Journal of Advertising, 36(5), 798-828.

https://doi.org/10.1080/02650487.2017.1348035

[5] Djafarova, E., & Rushworth, C. (2017). Exploring the credibility of online celebrities' Instagram profiles in influencing the purchase decisions of young female users. Computers in Human Behavior, 68, 1-7.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2016.11.009

[6] Gajjar, C., Chakrabarty, S. and Shah, P., 2022. Estimating the impact of corporate science-based emissions targets on India’s nationally determined contribution goals. Working Paper, World Resource Institute.
[7] Kay, S., Mulcahy, R., & Parkinson, J. (2020). When less is more: The impact of macro and micro social media influencers’ disclosure. Journal of Marketing Management, 36(3-4), 248-278.

https://doi.org/10.1080/0267257X.2020.1718740

[8] Khamis, S., Ang, L., & Welling, R. (2017). Self-branding, ‘micro-celebrity’ and the rise of Social Media Influencers. Celebrity Studies, 8(2), 191-208.

https://doi.org/10.1080/19392397.2016.1218292

[9] Kofluence. (2025). Decoding Influence: Kofluence's 2025 Influencer Marketing Report.
[10] Lou, C., & Yuan, S. (2019). Influencer marketing: How message value and credibility affect consumer trust of branded content on social media. Journal of Interactive Advertising, 19(1), 58-73.

https://doi.org/10.1080/15252019.2018.1533501

[11] Media Brief. (2025). India Influencer Report 2025 shows 322% growth in creator base.
[12] Media News 4U. (2025). The Rise of Vernacular Marketing: Connecting with Bharat Beyond English.
[13] Raghunat, K. M. K. and Merugu, P., 2025. Artificial Intelligence and Influencer Marketing: Strategies for Brand Building. In AI Impacts on Branded Entertainment and Advertising (pp. 167-188). IGI Global Scientific Publishing.
[14] Ramachandran, K. K., Suma, S., Banerjee, D., Mathew, B., Cheepurupalli, N. R. and Mohan, C. R., 2024. The Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing in the Age of AI. Journal of Informatics Education and Research, 4(2), p. 14.
[15] Tanwar, A. S., Chaudhry, H., & Srivastava, M. K. (2021). Influencer marketing as a tool of digital consumer engagement: A systematic literature review. Indian Journal of Marketing, 51(10), 27-42.

https://doi.org/10.17010/ijom/2021/v51/i10/166439

[16] Teklehaimanot, B., 2021. The evolution of influence marketing in Switzerland and its impact on Companies.
[17] Upadhyay, P. K. (2025). Empowering future generations: Analysing influencer marketing effect on consumer behaviour in Uttar Pradesh. Adhyayan: A Journal of Management Sciences, 15(1), 63-69.
[18] Wahl-Jorgensen, K. and Boelle, J., 2024. Vernacular journalism: Local news and everyday life. Journalism, 25(8), pp. 1603-1619.
[19] Reinold, T., & Tropp, L. R. (2018). The power of visual identity: Influencer marketing and the modern consumer. Journal of Marketing Communications, 24(6), 575-592.

https://doi.org/10.1080/13527266.2018.1488102

[20] Lim, X. J., Radzol, A. M., Cheah, J., & Wong, M. W. (2017). The impact of social media influencers on purchase intention and the mediating effect of customer attitude. Asian Journal of Business Research, 7(2), 1-13.

https://doi.org/10.14707/ajbr.v7i2.548

Cite This Article
Plain Text BibTeX RIS

  • APA Style

    Bansal, A. (2025). Bridging the Perception Gap: An Investigation into Consumer Trust and Brand Value in India's Influencer Ecosystem. International Journal of Business and Economics Research, 14(5), 194-210. https://doi.org/10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12

    Copy | Download

    ACS Style

    Bansal, A. Bridging the Perception Gap: An Investigation into Consumer Trust and Brand Value in India's Influencer Ecosystem. Int. J. Bus. Econ. Res. 2025, 14(5), 194-210. doi: 10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12

    Copy | Download

    AMA Style

    Bansal A. Bridging the Perception Gap: An Investigation into Consumer Trust and Brand Value in India's Influencer Ecosystem. Int J Bus Econ Res. 2025;14(5):194-210. doi: 10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12

    Copy | Download 

  • @article{10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12,
  author = {Anmol Bansal},
  title = {Bridging the Perception Gap: An Investigation into Consumer Trust and Brand Value in India's Influencer Ecosystem
},
  journal = {International Journal of Business and Economics Research},
  volume = {14},
  number = {5},
  pages = {194-210},
  doi = {10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12},
  url = {https://doi.org/10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12},
  eprint = {https://article.sciencepublishinggroup.com/pdf/10.11648.j.ijber.20251405.12},
  abstract = {This research investigates the complex dynamics of the influencer marketing ecosystem in India, focusing on the alignment and divergence between consumer trust, influencer strategies, and brand expectations. Through a quantitative analysis of 250 respondents, comprising 239 consumers and 21 influencers, this study examines the critical factors that shape audience perception, purchasing behavior, and platform engagement. The findings reveal a significant disconnect between the values prioritized by consumers and the metrics valued by brands. Consumers predicate their trust on perceived authenticity, personal connection, and relatable content, whereas brands are perceived to prioritize performance, reach, and content quality defined by engagement metrics. This core conflict is the primary driver of trust, particularly when content becomes overly commercialized or scripted. The study confirms a strong inverse correlation between consumer age and susceptibility to influencer persuasion, with younger demographics being most receptive. A notable "platform generation gap" is identified, with YouTube and Instagram showing universal appeal, while Facebook and X (formerly Twitter) exhibit highly age-segregated user bases. Analysis of purchasing behavior indicates that influencer recommendations are most effective for lifestyle-oriented categories such as fashion, electronics, and beauty, which are conducive to visual demonstration. Ultimately, this paper argues that the long-term sustainability of influencer marketing depends on bridging the gap between consumer expectations and creator strategies. It concludes that a strategic shift towards prioritizing authenticity over purely performance-based metrics, coupled with data-informed, age-tailored platform selection, is essential for maintaining audience trust and ensuring the continued efficacy of this marketing channel.
},
 year = {2025}
}

    Copy | Download 

  • TY  - JOUR
T1  - Bridging the Perception Gap: An Investigation into Consumer Trust and Brand Value in India's Influencer Ecosystem

AU  - Anmol Bansal
Y1  - 2025/10/27
PY  - 2025
N1  - https://doi.org/10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12
DO  - 10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12
T2  - International Journal of Business and Economics Research
JF  - International Journal of Business and Economics Research
JO  - International Journal of Business and Economics Research
SP  - 194
EP  - 210
PB  - Science Publishing Group
SN  - 2328-756X
UR  - https://doi.org/10.11648/j.ijber.20251405.12
AB  - This research investigates the complex dynamics of the influencer marketing ecosystem in India, focusing on the alignment and divergence between consumer trust, influencer strategies, and brand expectations. Through a quantitative analysis of 250 respondents, comprising 239 consumers and 21 influencers, this study examines the critical factors that shape audience perception, purchasing behavior, and platform engagement. The findings reveal a significant disconnect between the values prioritized by consumers and the metrics valued by brands. Consumers predicate their trust on perceived authenticity, personal connection, and relatable content, whereas brands are perceived to prioritize performance, reach, and content quality defined by engagement metrics. This core conflict is the primary driver of trust, particularly when content becomes overly commercialized or scripted. The study confirms a strong inverse correlation between consumer age and susceptibility to influencer persuasion, with younger demographics being most receptive. A notable "platform generation gap" is identified, with YouTube and Instagram showing universal appeal, while Facebook and X (formerly Twitter) exhibit highly age-segregated user bases. Analysis of purchasing behavior indicates that influencer recommendations are most effective for lifestyle-oriented categories such as fashion, electronics, and beauty, which are conducive to visual demonstration. Ultimately, this paper argues that the long-term sustainability of influencer marketing depends on bridging the gap between consumer expectations and creator strategies. It concludes that a strategic shift towards prioritizing authenticity over purely performance-based metrics, coupled with data-informed, age-tailored platform selection, is essential for maintaining audience trust and ensuring the continued efficacy of this marketing channel.

VL  - 14
IS  - 5
ER  -

    Copy | Download

Author Information
Download PDF
Submit an Article
  • Abstract
  • Keywords

  • Document Sections

    1. 1. Introduction
    2. 2. Methodology
    3. 3. Results and Discussions
    4. 4. Conclusion
    5. 5. Implications & Future Aspects
    6. 6. Limitations and Future Prospects
    Show Full Outline
  • Abbreviations
  • Acknowledgments
  • Author Contributions
  • Conflicts of Interest
  • References
  • Cite This Article
  • Author Information

About Us

Science Publishing Group (SciencePG) is an Open Access publisher, with more than 300 online, peer-reviewed journals covering a wide range of academic disciplines.

Learn More About SciencePG

Products

Information

Important Link

Copyright © 2012 -- 2025 Science Publishing Group – All rights reserved.