2. Methodology
This chapter presents the research process, that is, the methodological procedures and approaches adopted for its development. Initially, it was understood that conducting comprehensive research and analyzing the selected literature were of utmost importance, as they provided frameworks for refining the methodological pathways and thus enabling the completion of the study.
The emphasis falls primarily on bibliographic research, as this choice is justified by the fact that the selected method represents the first stage and, throughout this study, aims to gather information and data that will be used as foundation for the investigation on educational challenges in the final years of elementary school. Digital platforms were used to locate relevant works, namely: Google Scholar, SciELO, and Capes. This research analyzed various articles, books, theses, and other scientific works that discuss and present reflections and suggestions which may contribute to a deeper understanding of the theme presented in this article.
Thus, this is a qualitative study that offers reflections and values the experiences of the subjects involved. It employs a qualitative approach by focusing on obtaining descriptive data rather than numerical representation, being oriented towards analyzing the opinions of the research participants. According to the author:
The qualitative research approach has its roots in the late 19th century when social scientists began to question whether the investigation method used in physical and natural sciences, which was based on a positivist perspective of knowledge, should continue to serve as a model for studying human and social phenomena. [...] Dilthey [...] was one of the first to seek a different methodology for the social sciences, arguing that human and social phenomena are too complex and dynamic [...]. Furthermore, [...] the particular context in which an event occurs is an essential element for its understanding [...]
| [3] | ANDRÉ, M. D. A. Ethnography of school practice. 18th ed. Campinas: Papirus, 2012. |
[3]
.
Therefore, focusing on this study, the qualitative approach enables researchers to reflect on the responses provided by the research participants. Thus, it is believed that this approach aligned with our objectives, allowing for analyses and inferences about educational challenges in the final years of elementary school. Regarding the importance of this investigation, it aims to provoke reflections among teachers, administrators, and all those interested in this theme. Particularly concerning educational problems as non-neutral elements, since, consciously, teachers have intentionality when selecting them for the teaching-learning process. These elements must be directly connected to the content to be addressed, the lesson objectives, and especially to the reality of the students, the school, and the school community, thereby fostering a more effective teaching-learning process.
To this end, this research aimed to describe and explain how educational challenges are addressed and worked on with students in the classroom, as well as their potential contributions to student learning. We can describe explanatory research as:
This type of research is primarily concerned with identifying the factors that determine or contribute to the occurrence of phenomena. It is the type of research that most deepens the understanding of reality because it explains the reason, the "why" behind things. For this very reason, it is the most complex and delicate type, since the risk of committing errors increases considerably
| [19] | GIL, A. C. Social research methods and techniques. 6th ed. São Paulo: Atlas, 2008. |
[19]
.
Thus, these are studies that encompass the factors that either contribute to or hinder the occurrence of phenomena. Therefore, we considered it pertinent to report and discuss the main educational challenges faced by the school community in the final years of elementary education and to propose solutions to improve teaching quality and student performance.
3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Educational Challenges in Brazilian Education and Stakeholders in the Pursuit of Solutions
It is widely known that Brazilian education faces various complex challenges across all grade levels. Among these educational issues, one can cite school dropout, inadequate teaching quality, lack of infrastructure, student disobedience, social inequalities, among other problems. Research indicates that these problems are interconnected, requiring school management to adopt a rigorous, competent, and comprehensive approach to find solutions
| [28] | SAVIAN, Dermeval. Education in dialogue. Associated Authors, 2023. |
[28]
. Effective public policy investment, a qualified teaching staff, and adequate infrastructure are necessary to implement innovative methodologies capable of improving the quality of education in Brazil.
It is important to recall what is written in the Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil of 1988: "Education, which is the right of all and the duty of the State and the family, shall be promoted and encouraged with the collaboration of society, aiming at the full development of the person, his or her preparation for the exercise of citizenship, and his or her qualification for work"
. Society must be involved in addressing educational challenges, seeking to resolve problems through meetings and discussions, thereby ensuring the full academic development of students.
School management is extremely relevant in seeking solutions to problems, as it is at the forefront of educational challenges within the educational institution. It can be considered that school management must pursue knowledge and specializations to ensure better results. It can be regarded as a system that brings together people who share the same objectives, "considering the intentional nature of their actions and the social interactions they establish among themselves and with the socio-political context, in democratic forms of decision-making"
| [23] | LIBÂNEO, José Carlos. School organization and management: theory and practice. Goiânia: Alternativa, 2007. |
[23]
. The author uses the term school management when referring to a school leader. School management leads one to think about sharing ideas, where individuals work towards the proper functioning of the school, and decision-making occurs collectively through discussions held, adds
| [25] | OLIVEIRA, Ivana Campos; VASQUES-MENEZES, Ione. Literature review: the concept of school management. Research Notebooks, v. 48, n. 169, p. 876-900, 2018. |
[25]
. It is considered that for good management, the active participation of teachers and the broader school community is important to organize teaching and ensure educational quality for all students.
Another important stakeholder in addressing educational challenges are the families and guardians of students. With this purpose, it is important that teachers and family members know their students/children well. However, "it is necessary to emphasize that parents are of great importance for a healthy child development process"
| [11] | CARVALHO, Mônica Cabral de. Aggressiveness as a response of an individual raised in a dysfunctional family. Monograph. Candido Mendes University, Rio de Janeiro, 2010. |
[11]
. Furthermore, they should allow the development of their children's personal identity. Similarly:
Each school deals with this issue in its own way. It is very easy to perceive when a student is going through this type of difficulty. When a student who always completed activities starts neglecting them or becomes withdrawn, the educator should seek to talk with them, and then contact the coordination
| [31] | SOUZA, Aline Bianca Lima; BELEZA, Mirra Carla Moreira; ANDRADE, Roberta Ferreira Coelho de. New Family Arrangements and Challenges to Family Law: A reading of the Court of Justice of Amazonas 2012. Available at:
http://periodicos.unifap.br/index.php/pracs/article/view/577 Accessed on: May 17, 2024. |
[31]
.
Many educational challenges are related to students who did not have an adequate educational foundation. It is frequently observed that they were raised by grandparents, uncles/aunts, cousins, or older siblings, argues
. In pursuit of educational success, these aforementioned stakeholders are important in addressing educational problems.
There are various educational challenges. The authors state, "the main problems are the poor quality of schools and grade retention, that is, the tradition of holding back students who do not perform well on tests, a practice widely disseminated in Brazil"
| [29] | SCHWARTZMAN, Simon; BROCK, Colin. The challenges of education in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro: Nova Fronteira, v. 1320, 2005. |
[29]
. Besides these two issues, there are others that drastically affect the teaching-learning process across all grade levels.
It is worth adding regarding school dropout, characterized as "a symptom of a human development problem, whose roots are formed since early childhood. The accumulation of deficiencies in a child's development culminates in some cases in dropout, and in most cases, in low cognitive and socioemotional capacity, and low learning"
| [15] | FERREIRA, Sergio Guimarães; RIBEIRO, Giovanna; TAFNER, Paulo. School dropout and abandonment in Brazil. 2023. |
[15]
. Within this context, this issue is related to socioeconomic factors. Students from low-income families leave school due to the need to work and provide financial help at home, considers
| [21] | KUPPER, Agnaldo. Brazilian education: reflections and perspectives. Terra & Cultura Journal: Teaching and Research Notebooks, v. 20, n. 39, p. 50-60, 2020. |
[21]
). In such cases, it is necessary to talk to the family and monitor the attendance of these students, a situation that frequently occurs in Brazilian schools.
According to the author's perspective, Brazil faces issues of low teaching quality in its schools, an aspect that demands attention primarily from the state, notes
| [14] | DAMASCENO, Maria Nobre; BESERRA, Bernadete. Studies on rural education in Brazil: state of the art and perspectives. Education and Research, v. 30, p. 73-89, 2004. |
[14]
. The quality of education in Brazilian schools is widely questioned, encompassing shortcomings in pedagogical practices, inadequate teacher training, overcrowded classrooms, and a lack of resources. The methodology used in the classroom is highly indicative of educational success, as follows:
Traditional teaching methods have withstood the test of time, continuing to prevail in school practice. It is common in our schools to assign teaching the mere task of transmitting knowledge, overloading students with information that is memorized without question, assigning only repetitive exercises, imposing discipline externally, and using punishments [...]
| [22] | LIBÂNEO, C. J. Didactics. 2nd ed. São Paulo: Cortez, 2013. |
[22]
.
This is not to say that these techniques are irrelevant to the teaching process; however, by themselves, they make teaching tedious, repetitive, and devoid of interaction between teacher and student, student and student, nor allow for contextualization with social practices. Within this model, knowledge is imposed upon the learner, who is educated to achieve, through their own effort, their full self-realization as a person
| [22] | LIBÂNEO, C. J. Didactics. 2nd ed. São Paulo: Cortez, 2013. |
[22]
. Thus, it can be said that when teaching occurs solely in this one-directional manner (from teacher to student), knowledge can become neutral, as it does not enable the student to develop a critical perspective based on their own reality, remaining merely an act of memorization. From the author's point of view:
[...] in Brazilian education, three distinct meanings of quality have been constructed and have circulated both symbolically and concretely in society: a first one, conditioned by the limited supply of schooling opportunities; a second, related to the idea of flow, defined as the number of students who progress or not within a given education system; and finally, the idea of quality associated with performance assessment through large-scale tests
| [26] | OLIVEIRA, Romualdo Portela de; ARAUJO, Gilda Cardoso de. Quality of teaching: a new dimension in the struggle for the right to education. Brazilian Journal of Education, p. 5-23, 2005. |
[26]
.
Unlike other countries, Brazilian education is limited and offers only the basics. Another point that must be addressed concerns socioeconomic factors and inequalities, as noted by Savin
| [28] | SAVIAN, Dermeval. Education in dialogue. Associated Authors, 2023. |
[28]
. Rural and peripheral areas suffer from precarious infrastructure, a lack of resources, and access to low-quality education. Evidence suggests that "since education is a relatively complex activity and certainly also occurs outside the school environment, a list of determinants of educational inequalities can be quite extensive"
| [24] | MEDEIROS, Marcelo; OLIVEIRA, Luís Felipe Batista de. Regional inequalities in education: convergence potential. Society and State, v. 29, p. 561-585, 2014. |
[24]
. The lack of opportunities limits children's ability to attend school.
The lack of resources results in schools with precarious infrastructure, absence of libraries, laboratories, technological resources, and adequate classrooms, which can hinder the teaching-learning process. This directly affects the quality of education and the students' school environment, explain
| [29] | SCHWARTZMAN, Simon; BROCK, Colin. The challenges of education in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro: Nova Fronteira, v. 1320, 2005. |
[29]
. Building upon the idea advocated by the authors:
It does not seem, therefore, to be a justifiable educational policy to keep students and teachers in precariously equipped schools in such a deplorable state of repair. However the accounts are made, it is expensive to pay for learning over several years what could be learned in just one. Compared to what we are paying today (more than a year and a half of instruction for each grade completed and four dropouts for every student who finishes elementary school), everything else is ridiculously cheap
| [12] | CASTRO, C. M.; FLETCHER, P. The school that Brazilians attended in 1985. Brasilia: Ipea, 1986. |
[12]
.
It is evident that since 1986 schools were already in precarious conditions, and this scenario persists in many Brazilian schools, notes
| [21] | KUPPER, Agnaldo. Brazilian education: reflections and perspectives. Terra & Cultura Journal: Teaching and Research Notebooks, v. 20, n. 39, p. 50-60, 2020. |
[21]
. Addressing this significant challenge requires trained professionals to seek solutions. In this context, we emphasize the continuing education of school management and the teaching staff. Continuing education allows for the adaptation and use of new strategies within the educational system. Teachers should be able to conduct their classes not only using basic methods but must be proficient enough to find tools capable of enabling effective teaching, states
| [28] | SAVIAN, Dermeval. Education in dialogue. Associated Authors, 2023. |
[28]
. Ensuring the full development of students is a challenge, but utilizing creativity and dynamic approaches can change this situation. The National Common Curricular Base (BNCC)
| [7] | BRAZIL. Ministry of Education. National Common Curricular Base. Brasilia: Ministry of Education, 2018. |
[7]
recognized in 2018 that early childhood education is the primary foundation for a child's future development; thus, it is essential to innovate teaching methods to facilitate learning and the construction of new pathways, considering the child as the central focus in the classroom.
The teacher creates interdisciplinary learning environments, proposes challenges and explorations that can lead to discoveries and promote the construction of knowledge using the computer and its programs (software) to problematize and implement projects
| [1] | ALMEIDA, M. E. Informatics and teacher education. Brasilia: Ministry of Education, 2010. |
[1]
.
However difficult it may be to deal with this issue in the classroom, there are strategies to manage the situation until a plausible solution emerges. Numerous studies highlight teachers who find great difficulty in delivering these contents, both due to the school's physical aspect and the lack of adequate teaching materials, as exposed by
.
As can be observed, the educational challenges are numerous. Crucially, literacy education is fundamental, especially for marginalized students. Many students reach the end of elementary school without the necessary knowledge to advance to the next grade, possessing only basic skills in reading, writing, and mathematics, characterize
| [14] | DAMASCENO, Maria Nobre; BESERRA, Bernadete. Studies on rural education in Brazil: state of the art and perspectives. Education and Research, v. 30, p. 73-89, 2004. |
[14]
. A conducted study reveals that "learning difficulties are very present in schools, as a common complaint among educators. Various factors cause essential issues to be overlooked while others are amplified and left unresolved"
| [5] | ARAÚJO, Marli Ferreira de. Learning difficulties in the literacy process. 2011. |
[5]
. It is important to emphasize the insufficient class time available to develop further strategies to address these educational challenges.
These educational challenges represent complex issues that require measures and strategies at governmental, social, and educational levels to be eliminated from Brazilian education. This necessitates society's attention through meetings to discuss the problems that most concern educational development, while also resorting to strategies and new methodologies that yield positive results for the teaching-learning process.
3.2. Challenges Faced in the Final Years of Elementary School
Based on various sources analyzed, educational challenges in the final years of elementary school are an evident issue. Teachers daily seek strategies aimed at changing the educational landscape for these young students. Evidence indicates that students in the initial grades face difficulties in the teaching-learning process, such as disinterest in learning, socioeconomic reality, and problems in writing and reading. In this context, there is a concern to find approaches to solve the problems and educational challenges present in the final years of elementary school.
As previously presented, educational challenges are related to all grade levels. This topic, in particular, is intended to discuss the educational challenges of the final years of elementary school. The final years of elementary school comprise grades 6 to 9, and educational challenges are observed in Brazilian schools
| [18] | GATTI, Bernardete A. Teacher education in Brazil: characteristics and problems. Education & Society, v. 31, p. 1355-1379, 2010. |
[18]
. Therefore, some educational issues are present at this stage of education. It is worth mentioning that:
Learning Disabilities (L. D.) are problems related to a series of factors and can manifest in various ways, such as: disorders, significant difficulties in understanding and using listening, speaking, reading, writing, reasoning, and developing mathematical skills. These disorders are inherent to the individual, possibly resulting from central nervous system dysfunction, and may occur throughout the lifespan. Also associated with these learning difficulties may be problems related to the individual's behavior, social perception, and social interaction, but these do not, by themselves, constitute a learning disability
| [17] | GARCIA, J. N. Handbook of learning difficulties: reading, writing and mathematics. Porto Alegre: Artes Médicas, 1998. |
[17]
.
The numerous observed problems hinder student learning. This finding is closely related to learning gaps, as many students reach the final years of elementary school with significant learning deficits, notes
| [2] | ALVES, Maria Teresa Gonzaga; SOARES, José Francisco. School context and educational indicators: unequal conditions for the effectiveness of an educational assessment policy. Education and Research, v. 39, n. 1, p. 177-194, 2013. |
[2]
. From the author's perspective:
The finding that a significant portion of students who reach the final years of Elementary School presents great difficulties in reading, writing, and text comprehension is widely reported in the press, especially when it publicizes the results of diagnostic assessments such as Prova Brasil, SAEB, Prova ABC, and PISA, among others
| [27] | PEREIRA, Gilvan Elias et al. The student in the final years of elementary school (from public schools) with significant gaps in reading and writing skills: investigating subjects and contexts. 2011. |
[27]
.
These results reflect the state of student learning and, consequently, allow for the annual observation of learning levels through these assessments. Students leaving elementary school with an educational gap hinders their performance in high school
| [18] | GATTI, Bernardete A. Teacher education in Brazil: characteristics and problems. Education & Society, v. 31, p. 1355-1379, 2010. |
[18]
. This results in low outcomes for Brazil's overall educational development.
According to the authors' understanding, other educational challenges plaguing elementary education are demotivation and lack of engagement. The school management and teaching staff must understand the students' reality, explain
| [9] | BZUNECK, José Aloyseo; MEGLIATO, Jucyla Guimarães Peres; RUFINI, Sueli Édi. Engagement of adolescents in school homework: a person-centered approach. School and Educational Psychology, v. 17, p. 151-161, 2013. |
[9]
. School management is responsible for seeking solutions to problems, using meetings to encourage the use of different methodologies that engage students in their lessons. Similarly, "an important consideration of school motivation from a qualitative perspective relies on the sense of autonomy. Thus, alongside students motivated merely by controlling forces, there are others who can be motivated through autonomy"
| [9] | BZUNECK, José Aloyseo; MEGLIATO, Jucyla Guimarães Peres; RUFINI, Sueli Édi. Engagement of adolescents in school homework: a person-centered approach. School and Educational Psychology, v. 17, p. 151-161, 2013. |
[9]
. Various methodologies can be found to seek solutions to some problems. Regarding engagement, it "means the student's active involvement in a task or learning activity, in class or in another environment"
| [9] | BZUNECK, José Aloyseo; MEGLIATO, Jucyla Guimarães Peres; RUFINI, Sueli Édi. Engagement of adolescents in school homework: a person-centered approach. School and Educational Psychology, v. 17, p. 151-161, 2013. |
[9]
. It is important to emphasize that all members of the school community must be committed to the same objectives.
In this reality, school dropout is a problem present across all grade levels. In the final years of elementary school, students often end up leaving the classroom to help support their families, states
| [31] | SOUZA, Aline Bianca Lima; BELEZA, Mirra Carla Moreira; ANDRADE, Roberta Ferreira Coelho de. New Family Arrangements and Challenges to Family Law: A reading of the Court of Justice of Amazonas 2012. Available at:
http://periodicos.unifap.br/index.php/pracs/article/view/577 Accessed on: May 17, 2024. |
[31]
. This is one of the reasons why children do not complete their studies. The author comments:
In this sense, it is necessary to consider that school dropout is a problematic situation, produced by a series of determinants. It is important to clarify that the term 'school dropout' will be understood as a result of the student's academic failure and that of the school institution itself, as will be seen later when studying the causes and consequences of school dropout, as well as its effects on school productivity
| [13] | CERATTI, Márcia Rodrigues Neves. School dropout: causes and consequences. Curitiba, 2008. |
[13]
.
Considering the points presented, the author further elaborates on the idea of school dropout as "involving students' cognitive and psycho-emotional issues, sociocultural and institutional factors, and those related to economics and politics"
| [13] | CERATTI, Márcia Rodrigues Neves. School dropout: causes and consequences. Curitiba, 2008. |
[13]
. This is a problem that the school must address together with the family and guardians of these students, understanding their environment and financial situation. Here, it is crucial to emphasize that school dropout is linked to socioeconomic issues, making knowledge of the student's social context essential.
Continuing with the educational challenges in the final years of elementary school, violence and indiscipline in schools have been increasing significantly. Both teachers and students feel insecure and this affects their interaction in the classroom. As reported:
It is necessary to distinguish school indiscipline from other forms of violence that sometimes affect school life, often caused by individuals external to it. While school indiscipline can border on delinquency, it rarely is delinquency, as it does not violate the legal order of society, but only the order established within the school to meet the needs of collectively organized learning.
| [34] | ESTRELLA, T. M. Pedagogical relationship, discipline, and indiscipline in the classroom. Porto, Portugal: Porto Editora, 2002. |
[34]
.
This violence and indiscipline are related to teachers, principals, students, and society. This is a concerning problem that plagues the entire school community. Students in the final years of elementary school are beginning to encounter numerous opportunities, and it is through these opportunities that they sometimes find the wrong path, as indicated by
| [8] | BRITO, Clovis da Silva; SANTOS, Lucélia Gonçalves dos. Indiscipline and violence in schools. In: IX National Congress on Education-EDUCERE & III South Brazilian Meeting on Psychopedagogy-PUCPR. 2009. p. 10719-10729. |
[8]
. It is the beginning of youth, a time when new ideas and friendships emerge. In this manner:
In Brazil, the phenomenon of school violence has received special attention from fields such as Education, Social Sciences, and Psychology, with a growing body of scientific research since the end of the last century. It is also a concern for society as a whole and the media, particularly regarding its most visible form physical violence or violence against property
| [33] | VÓVIO, Claudia Lemos et al. Occurrence books: violence and indiscipline in schools in vulnerable territories. Education Policy Analysis Archives, v. 24, p. 126-126, 2016. |
[33]
.
Violence and undisciplined students are present in all Brazilian schools, making it a relevant issue to be discussed and requiring urgent strategic solutions. It is pertinent to consider ongoing teacher training to deal with undisciplined students. Therefore, "to be a teacher in current times, it is essential to constantly broaden professional competencies, considering that knowledge and society are constantly transforming worldwide"
| [30] | SILVA, Jerto Cardoso da et al. Mental health, illness, and teaching work. School and Educational Psychology, v. 27, p. e242262, 2023. |
[30]
. The lack of specific training to work with adolescents and the need for pedagogical updating are constant challenges.
It is also necessary to address inclusive education. Students with special needs still face significant barriers, including lack of teacher preparedness, absence of specialized resources and adequate methodologies, and insufficient school infrastructure. Within this conception, Andreozzi
| [4] | ANDREOZZI, Maria Luiza. Inclusive education: school failure of education in modernity. Education and Subjectivity, Faculty of Education, PUCSP, v. 1, p. 43-75, 2015. |
[4]
points out the need to remove the barrier constructed between education and disability, emphasizing the necessity of means to introduce individuals with disabilities into the school environment. For this, the role of the specialized teacher is fundamental to improve the student's integration in their academic and social journey. Similarly, Camargo and Carvalho
| [10] | CAMARGO, Flávia Pedrosa de; CARVALHO, Cynthia Paes de. The right to education of students with disabilities: management of inclusive education policy in municipal schools according to implementing agents. Brazilian Journal of Special Education, v. 25, p. 617-634, 2019. |
[10]
state that the teacher has the role of assisting the student with special educational needs so that they can advance both intellectually and socially. In this way, these students can surpass the expectations and barriers created for them, being able to enjoy their rights.
The practice of including students with special educational needs at all levels of education is currently an educational policy guaranteed by legislation, in both public and private networks in Brazil, although it has not yet been fully achieved across the entire national territory. Thus, Andreozzi
| [4] | ANDREOZZI, Maria Luiza. Inclusive education: school failure of education in modernity. Education and Subjectivity, Faculty of Education, PUCSP, v. 1, p. 43-75, 2015. |
[4]
argues that adaptation in all areas, in conjunction with federal and municipal bodies, is essential for effective integration. In summary, Figueira
| [16] | FIGUEIRA, Emílio. Inclusive Education-How to Prepare Monographs. Clube de Autores, 2019. |
[16]
notes that governmental bodies guarantee and assist the processes ensured by law, in addition to sharing the necessary materials with these institutions for the better integration of individuals with disabilities in the school space. It is necessary to work and direct inclusive education towards hard-to-reach areas, as they suffer the most from exclusion in Brazil. The institution should also present methodologies for unifying the school and the student, making the student feel included in the school environment.